The first part of this series on litigation avoidance discussed the business case for preventing unnecessary litigation. Part two focused on startups and the steps startups can take to grow without unnecessarily creating legal disputes. This third installment zeroes in on employment law. Based on a recent report, 26,635 federal employment cases were filed in 2025, the highest number in the report’s ten-year dataset.[1] Many of these disputes could likely have been avoided, or at least made easier to defend, through relatively straightforward measures.

While this article is not intended to catalogue every employment-law requirement or every issue that can arise, it highlights some of the recurring problems we see in litigation and practical steps employers and HR professionals can take before those problems become lawsuits. If you’re pressed for time, check out the last section where we’ve included a checklist summarizing the most important action items for employers.

1. Start at Hiring: Know Who You Are Hiring and on What Terms

Employment considerations start earlier than many employers may think. Even before someone is hired, employers should give some thought to how a position is advertised, how candidates are selected and interviewed, and what happens once an offer is made. Federal, state and local law may affect the process, including what information belongs in a job posting (some states require salary range information) and what employers should, or should not, ask during an interview (for example, the Americans with Disabilities Act governs questions about disabilities). For remote and hybrid workers in particular, employers should also know where the employee will actually be working because that location may determine which state and local employment laws apply. And once the right person has been selected, the focus shifts to clearly defining and documenting the relationship.

Special attention should be paid to documenting compensation arrangements, in particular when incentive compensation, such as bonuses or equity, is involved. An informal promise that “we will take care of you when we raise the next round” may sound harmless when everyone is optimistic and getting along. Years later, after the company succeeds, precisely what was promised, by whom, and with what conditions may be worth a great deal of money.[2]

Another important consideration at the time of hiring is the classification: will the hired person be an employee or an independent contractor? For startups and smaller businesses, engaging independent contractors often seems easier and cheaper than hiring employees. But just calling someone an “independent contractor” does not make that person one. Instead, there are legal rules about the types of relationships that can qualify for independent contractor status, and those rules look at the actual substance of the relationship. This matters because employees have more rights than contractors, and if a business has misclassified a worker, it might inadvertently create an expensive legal problem. Businesses should also monitor any evolving relationships; a genuine independent contractor engaged for a specific project may gradually assume responsibilities and become integrated into the business in ways that turn them into an employee.

The same attention is necessary for employees classified as “exempt” from being owed overtime payments. Exemptions depend on the employee’s salary and job responsibilities. A clear and accurate job description can be helpful, but courts look at the employee’s actual duties. If the claimed overtime exemption does not fit the employee’s actual duties, what began as one employee’s payroll question can become a wage-and-hour dispute involving an entire category of workers.

The decisions made at hiring set the terms of the relationship. Once an employee starts work, many of the issues that later become litigation develop in the day-to-day management of the relationship: the policies a company adopts, whether supervisors know and follow them, how performance issues are handled, and whether employees are treated consistently.

2. During Employment: Have Clear Rules and Follow Them

Good, written workplace policies are important and should create clear rules about wages and hours, leave and accommodation, workplace conduct, anti-harassment and anti-discrimination, reporting procedures, confidentiality, technology use, and other important topics. They should also be legally compliant in the states and cities where employees actually work, not simply where the company is headquartered. A New York company may have employees working remotely in California, Massachusetts, Florida, or Europe, each potentially implicating different rules concerning wages, leave, required training, restrictive covenants, discrimination, privacy, and termination. Employers should consult with employment counsel in preparing and periodically updating their handbooks, policies, and related employment documents.

But policies are only useful if people know and follow them. Employers should make sure that new hires receive the applicable policies and that employees are informed when important policies change. Just as important: the company’s actual practices should match its written policies. A well-drafted handbook is of limited help in litigation if supervisors routinely handle the same issue differently.

Some of the easiest compliance steps, like annual anti-harassment training, are also the easiest to forget. We recommend that employers calendar recurring requirements, including trainings, periodic policy reviews and acknowledgments, and appropriate payroll and classification reviews, rather than relying on someone to remember when they become due. Policies should also be revisited when the workforce expands into a new jurisdiction or other material circumstances change. If litigation later arises, particularly a discrimination or harassment claim, a contemporaneous record showing that the employer regularly reviewed its policies, conducted required training, and took compliance seriously can be helpful evidence of the employer’s practices.

Another issue is how to deal with performance issues and other difficult situations. Sullivan & Worcester’s recent article, Managing Performance, Managing Risk, makes an important point: for some topics, such as illegal drug use at the workplace, an employer can reduce risk by maintaining “strict, clear rules.” Where judgment or a case-by-case decision is necessary, employers should still strive for consistency, consider legitimate business factors, and base decisions on neutral business reasons. For example, if two employees engage in materially similar conduct but receive very different discipline, the employer should be able to identify and document the legitimate reason for the difference, such as a different disciplinary history.

Two things are of particular importance: supervisor training and documentation. Supervisors should know how to give candid performance feedback, handle difficult conversations, document concerns appropriately, and recognize when HR or legal should be involved. A manager who rates an employee “excellent” every year because difficult conversations are uncomfortable creates a problem when the company later says that the employee has been a poor performer for years. The same principle applies to documentation: issues should be documented accurately when they occur, not reconstructed months later when the employer is considering discipline or termination. As Managing Performance, Managing Risk explains, contemporaneous emails, Teams or Slack messages, and follow-up emails after verbal discussions can help establish what concerns actually existed and when they arose.

3. When an Employee Raises a Concern: Take It Seriously

One situation comes up with surprising frequency: an employee tells a supervisor about harassment, discrimination, retaliation, or another serious workplace issue and then adds, “I just wanted you to know, but please don’t do anything about it.” That request does not necessarily end the matter. An employer with notice of potentially serious misconduct may need to respond even when the employee would prefer otherwise. At a minimum, the concern should be escalated to the people responsible for determining the appropriate response. As discussed above, supervisors therefore need training not merely on prohibited conduct, but on what to do when someone brings a concern to them.

Complaints should be taken seriously, investigated appropriately, and documented. The investigation does not always have to resemble a corporate internal investigation conducted by outside counsel. What it does need is a process appropriate to the allegation, reasonable impartiality, a reliable record of what was reviewed and learned, and a reasoned decision about what happens next. Some jurisdictions impose specific requirements. California regulations, for example, require covered employers to maintain a written harassment, discrimination, and retaliation prevention policy that includes a complaint process providing for timely responses, impartial and timely investigations, documentation and tracking, remedial options, and timely closure.

Taking a complaint seriously, of course, does not mean assuming it is true. Employees can misunderstand events or complain about conduct that is unpleasant but lawful. The important point is to assess the complaint rather than ignore it, and to document the response appropriately. Employers should also be cautious about promising absolute confidentiality when that may not be possible.

Retaliation becomes an important consideration at this stage as well. An employee who complains does not become immune from ordinary performance management. But discipline following legally-protected activity (such as a good faith complaint of discrimination) can create a legal risk. This is one more reason why consistent practices and contemporaneous documentation before a complaint occurs are so important—if there was a longstanding issue, but an employer did not impose discipline until after a whistleblower complaint, that discipline may appear retaliatory.

4. Disability Accommodations: A Workplace Policy Is Not Always the End of the Discussion

Employee requests for disability accommodations deserve particular attention, especially in light of the increase in federal accommodation litigation (see fn. 1). A company may have a legitimate and important company-wide requirement/policy, but when an employee says a disability prevents their compliance with the policy and requests an accommodation, “that is our policy” is not a sufficient answer. Legally speaking, an employer must consider a reasonable accommodation that would allow a qualified employee with a disability to perform the essential functions of the job, unless the accommodation would impose an undue hardship on the employer. What that means in plain English: an employer should engage with the employee to understand the limitation, thoughtfully consider the requirements of the role, and then determine whether an effective accommodation is available. Depending on the circumstances, that might involve modified equipment or workplace procedures, a change in schedule, leave, or a remote-work arrangement. The accommodation does not necessarily have to be the particular one requested by the employee as long as it addresses their limitation.

From a litigation-avoidance perspective, the process matters. Employers should document the request, the information considered, the discussion with the employee, and the reason an accommodation was granted, modified, or denied. A quick rejection based solely on a generally applicable policy can create an unnecessary problem, particularly where no one considered whether an alternative would have allowed the employee to do the job.

5. Restrictive Covenants: Know What the Law Allows

Non-competes and non-solicitation restrictions are another area where an outdated or inflexible template can create unnecessary problems. There is currently no nationwide non-compete ban in effect, but state law varies substantially on the subject. California, Minnesota, North Dakota, and Oklahoma, for example, generally prohibit employee non-competes, while many other states impose compensation thresholds or other significant restrictions. With remote work and employees being spread among many states, employers must check the state and local laws for each employee for which they want to implement a restrictive covenant.

Employers should start with a practical question: What does the company actually need to protect? The agreement should then be tailored to that interest, the employee, and applicable state law. A covenant that cannot realistically be enforced does little to protect the business, and threatening to enforce one without first checking the applicable law can turn a manageable employee departure into litigation.

6. Termination: Get the Process and the Record Right

Termination is where many employment issues escalate into litigation, so it is worth slowing down before making a decision about termination. The basic review need not be complicated: What is the reason for the termination? Does the employment agreement and existing record support it? Has something recently occurred, such as a complaint, accommodation request, leave, wage complaint, or other protected activity, that warrants additional consideration? Are there contractual or legal requirements that need to be addressed?[3]

Once again, our strong recommendation is to document, in writing, the answers to these questions. It does not have to be an elaborate memorandum, but the notes and record should be clear on the reason for the termination so someone unfamiliar with the history can later understand what happened and why.

By the time a disgruntled employee’s demand letter arrives, many of the important facts are already fixed. When a company has counsel review a contemplated termination (and any related internal investigation, accommodation dispute, or restrictive-covenant issue), potential problems can be identified while the company still has options. Thus, a short legal review before action is taken may prevent a much larger problem later.

7. Employment Litigation Avoidance Checklist

The foregoing recommendations can be summarized in the following checklist. While many of these steps are straightforward, the key is to put them in place early, before a problem arises and they are actually needed.

At Hiring

  • Documentation: Protect the business with strong, appropriate confidentiality and invention-assignment agreements that comply with state and federal law.
  • Classification: Review both employee/contractor and exempt/non-exempt classifications based on what the person actually does, not simply the job title or preference for a certain type of arrangement.
  • Compensation and equity: Be precise, document material terms and avoid informal promises that are not reflected in approved documents.
  • Residence of employee/contractor: Know where the person will work and where the person lives. Location may determine important legal requirements.

During Employment

  • Policies: Maintain and update the handbook and policies. Have the documents developed and periodically reviewed by employment counsel.
  • Train supervisors: Managers should know how to provide feedback, document issues, respond to complaints, and escalate concerns.
  • Apply rules consistently: Employees in the same situation should generally be treated the same. Any differences in treatment should be decided based on clear, legitimate considerations.
  • Document in real time: Keep current documentation about employment-related issues (such as bad performance), rather than trying to recreate the record later.
  • Schedule recurring tasks: Maintain a recurring calendar for the required trainings, policy reviews, acknowledgments, and recurring payroll and classification reviews.

When an Issue Arises

  • Take complaints seriously (including ones made verbally).
  • Investigate and document the process. The goal is not to assume the complaint is correct, but to reach a reasoned conclusion based on an appropriate review.
  • Treat disability accommodation requests as the beginning of a process, and work with the employee to find a solution, if possible. Document the process and the decision on accommodation.
  • Check restrictive-covenant law before threatening enforcement.
  • Involve employment counsel early when issues develop. Sensitive investigations, accommodation disputes, executive departures, wage-and-hour issues, and threatened employee claims are generally easier to address before positions harden.

At Termination

  • Make sure the reason for termination is clear and legitimate (even if the reason is not communicated in detail to the employee).
  • Check for recent protected activity (e.g. complaints, accommodations, leave) or other circumstances that warrant additional review.
  • Review applicable agreements and local requirements (e.g. notice requirement, timing of final pay, mandatory notices).
  • Involve employment counsel where the circumstances warrant it, particularly where there has been a recent complaint, accommodation request, leave, wage issue, investigation, or other flag for litigation risk. Have employment counsel draft or review separation agreements.

These are just some best practices. They cannot guarantee that an employer will never be sued—as discussed in Part I of this series, litigation avoidance does not mean avoiding difficult decisions or legitimate disputes. The goal instead is to avoid unnecessary issues and litigation risk and to be in a better position if a dispute ensues. Employment claims are easier to prevent, resolve, or defend when the company has sensible rules, supervisors understand their responsibilities, complaints are taken seriously, decisions have legitimate reasons, and the contemporaneous record supports those reasons. And these practices not only help avoid litigation, but they help support an environment of fairness and accountability for all workers.


[1] Lex Machina, Employment Litigation Report 2026 3, 6, 10–11 (2026) (reporting 26,635 federal employment cases, 20,265 federal employment-discrimination cases, and 6,785 federal employment-accommodation cases filed in 2025).

[2] Read our post “How Bonuses and Commissions Go Wrong” here: https://www.sullivanlaw.com/viewpoints/how-bonuses-and-commissions-go-wrong

[3] For example, some states require that final wages are paid on the termination date.