Our employment attorneys have years of experience advising clients on how to manage human resources most productively, with an emphasis on "preventive maintenance" and litigation avoidance. In addition to guiding company leaders on human resources matters, we also provide services to employees and executives seeking highly responsive and experienced legal guidance and advocacy.

We assist in formulating effective and dependable procedures for all phases of the employment relationship. At the hiring stage, we guide employers in complying with pay transparency laws and other evolving legal areas, prepare offer letters and employment contracts, and protect intellectual property through non-competition, non-solicitation, and confidentiality agreements.

We partner with our clients to create workplace policies that meet the needs of their workforces. We regularly assist clients in designing paid time off (including unlimited PTO) policies, policies for parental and disability needs, and policies for remote and hybrid work. We prepare anti-discrimination and retaliation policies, and we lead live trainings to educate workforces about appropriate workplace behavior.

Together with our compensation and benefits colleagues, we have the expertise to provide fast and cost-effective answers to “quick questions” and the depth to assist our clients with a wide variety of employment and tax-related issues including internal investigations, state law payroll compliance, assisting in exempt versus non-exempt employment classification for FLSA purposes, and advising on the often complex issue of employment versus independent contractor status.  We also routinely support clients in merger and acquisition transactions, including assisting with diligence, which often involves many of these just mentioned issues, and negotiation representations and covenants.

When especially delicate employment situations arise – including requests for religious or medical accommodation, allegations of harassment and discrimination, employee underperformance, and theft of intellectual property – we provide timely and savvy solutions.

When crisis and discord are unavoidable, we are poised to respond swiftly and decisively. We meet litigation threats with prompt risk assessment and experience-based strategy. Our practice group includes seasoned litigators who concentrate in employment-related disputes and adversary proceedings, including issues of unlawful termination, discrimination, breach of contract, covenants not to compete, compensation disputes, and benefit claims.

Our employment law team is backstopped by our compensation and benefits colleagues who are well versed in issues affecting employment law, such as helping to craft tax-efficient employment and severance arrangements, payroll reporting and withholding, and managing risk, including risk associated with Internal Revenue Code Sections 162(m), 280G, 4999, and 409A.

Employment & Benefits Practice Areas

Employment & Benefits

Compensation & Benefits Plan Design and Administration

Executive Compensation

ERISA Fiduciary

Viewpoints
All Viewpoints
Managing Performance, Managing Risk
When an employment relationship sours, the company’s performance management process can be a dangerous smoking gun—or its best defense. The thin line between unfairness and discrimination Employees do not have a statutory right to “fairness” in their performance reviews, workplace expectations, or discipline. If two employees violate the same policy, it is not automatically illegal to fire one and give the other a second chance. Yet unfairness is risky. Even when a company has a legitimate reason to take action, discrimination and retaliation must not influence the decision. If two employees consume alcohol at work, and the 30-year-old is given a second chance, but the 60-year-old is terminated, that employee may have a claim for age discrimination. If a retail company fires an employee for not making her sales goal, but there are other employees with worse numbers and the fired employee recently reported sexual harassment, the fired employee may have a claim for retaliation. One option is to maintain strict, clear rules. This can be a workable option for certain issues, such as illegal drug use at the workplace. But many performance issues require case-by-case decisions based on the full context. In those situations, a company can still reduce its legal risk by maintaining consistency where appropriate; thoughtfully deliberating about the legitimate business issues relevant to the situation; and committing itself to reaching decisions that reflect neutral business reasons alone. A solid approach from the very beginning helps to rebut allegations that the company acted because of bias or retaliation. Legal counsel can help guide an appropriate process. Respect for legal rights Employers should make sure that employees are judged for their performance, not their protected attributes or their protected actions. For example, an employee must not be criticized for working remotely if their employer previously approved that as a reasonable accommodation for their disability. An employee who took parental leave must not be criticized for taking that leave. Sometimes, an employee’s legal rights and their genuine performance issues intersect, such as when an employee has a disability that affects their work. Neither cancels the other, and legal counsel can help navigate these situations. Clarity and miscommunication Even when employers know they are providing neutral feedback, vague statements can be taken out of context and become legally dangerous. For example, a particular department might have one older worker within a younger team. A statement that the older worker should try to fit in better with the team culture could sound ageist. If there is a real, non-discriminatory problem—such as that the older worker is the only person on the team who does not answer questions from colleagues—the specific problem should be clearly identified. Supervisors and managers should be thoughtful whenever they are communicating with their team, whether in a verbal conversation, a formal performance review, or the many steps in between. When an employment relationship breaks down, even casual remarks are scrutinized, and vague or off-hand remarks can be taken as evidence of bias even if none was intended. For example, a statement that “Anne complains too much” might be referencing Anne’s whining about the slow printer, but if Anne has made a complaint of race discrimination, that statement could be understood another way. That casual comment could ultimately be presented to a jury, which will decide whose interpretation it believes. The flip side is that sometimes, managers use overly generous language (or give inflated numerical scores on performance reviews). The manager might be trying to be nice or simply trying to avoid confrontation. This is dangerous because it gives an employee false information about how the organization sees them. If that employee’s performance remains stable, and the employee is fired for underperformance before the next review cycle, the employee will understandably feel blindsided. The employee will also have evidence—created by the company itself—that directly undermines the company’s version of events. This could make the company vulnerable to an argument that it acted for a different, illegal reason. A truthful performance review gives an employee the opportunity to improve performance while avoiding a credibility crisis. If a tree falls in the forest, and no one sends a contemporaneous email, did it even happen? Annual performance reviews are important, but documenting performance issues should not be a once-a-year event. Emails, Teams messages, and Slack messages are all legitimate ways to discuss expectations and performance throughout the year. Verbal communications are also important, but they are vulnerable to different recollections. When a live conversation is preferred, consider a follow-up email to memorialize the substance. If an employee is terminated because of performance problems that arose between review cycles, but the performance issues were never documented in an email or other written message, the company could have a hard time proving that they were real. If an employee alleges that her firing was discriminatory, and the employer claims it was for legitimate reasons, the employee may argue that the so-called legitimate reasons are “pretextual.” If a judge or jury ultimately agrees that the employer’s stated reasons are pretextual, then an employee may win even without independent evidence of discrimination.[1] Similarly, an employee might take medical leave, support unionization, or take any other step that triggers anti-retaliation protections. Once those protections apply, an employee may argue that subsequent performance criticisms were not sincere, but retaliatory. In fact, in Massachusetts, when an employee takes paid family and medical leave, there is a presumption of retaliation for negative employment actions that happen during and even for 6 months after leave. Concerns that are documented before the employee announced an upcoming leave can be crucial in showing that the employer acted for legitimate reasons. By giving employees timely feedback as a standard practice, managers can reduce the risk that legitimate, performance-based decisions will be seen as retaliation.   Mid-year performance check-ins can involve a delicate balance between (1) providing necessary feedback so that the employee can understand expectations for success and (2) protecting the company in case the situation deteriorates. These two goals are compatible, but not identical. For example, a manager trying to be diplomatic might write: “I’d like you to take the lead in setting a collegial tone for the next meeting.” But if the backstory is that this very employee instigated a screaming match at the last meeting, that won’t be a very helpful piece of evidence. Conclusion Strong performance management limits legal risk while guiding employees toward success for themselves and for the organization. Legal counsel can help identify vulnerabilities and navigate any tension between risk exposure and business needs. Finally, employers should make sure that any discipline is consistent with any applicable employment contract or union agreement. [1] This is the law in Massachusetts, which is a “pretext-only” jurisdiction. Other jurisdictions apply a “pretext-plus” standard, which means a plaintiff employee cannot rely on pretext alone to win. This article is not legal advice. If you are interested in discussing any of these topics further, please contact a member of the Employment & Benefits Practice Group.
Lawsuits Are What Bring Us Together: "The Princess Bride" and the Law (Part 1)
First, a crucial clarification. While The Princess Bride (the wonderful movie) has the frame narrative of a grandfather who reads the book to his grandson, The Princess Bride (the wonderful book) has the frame narrative of a man whose father read it to him, and who wants to share it with his own son. The book is out of print, and the man sends his lawyer to a used bookstore during a blizzard. Although it’s always heartwarming when the lawyer is the hero of a favorite story… Clients: I esteem you; I cherish you; scavenger hunts during snowstorms are outside the scope of my litigation and employment practice. Please call the mergers and acquisitions team. Can Buttercup recover emotional distress damages from Ryan (a/k/a the Dread Pirate Roberts)? Promptly after Buttercup and Westley declared their mutual love, Westley was kidnapped by pirates and presumed murdered. Buttercup “never loved again” and “died that day.” In Massachusetts (and this article makes the common-sense assumption that Florin and the Commonwealth have largely identical legal systems), individuals can sometimes recover damages for their own emotional pain because of harm against a loved one. This type of claim depends on a close, preexisting relationship with the victim. Immediate family counts; Massachusetts is not very clear on which other relationships count. On the one hand, Westley had been working on Buttercup’s family farm for quite some time; they were in love, and he left to earn money for their marriage. On the other hand, for almost its entire length, their relationship consisted of demands for assorted manual tasks and repeated acquiescence. There might be some room for argument either way—at least at the time that Westley’s ship was captured. But these emotional distress claims are limited to certain relationships because of principles of foreseeability, and abstract questions about errands and “as you wish” became much less important when Westley begged for his life by putting the pirate on actual knowledge that true love was waiting for him at home. Once Ryan knew that Buttercup existed and had a vested interest in Westley’s well-being, Ryan couldn’t have been surprised that Buttercup was perturbed. Yet he spent the next three (3) years keeping Westley as a prisoner and threatening to kill him in the morning. The bigger issue for Buttercup’s lawsuit is that, to recover emotional distress damages, the loved one typically must have witnessed the harm or its immediate aftermath. By the time Buttercup was reunited with Westley, he wasn’t just not captured, but a thriving, rock-climbing small-business owner.  But Inigo could sue the Six-Fingered Man for murdering his father in front of him, right? Oh, definitely. Did Westley tortiously interfere with Vizzini’s business deal with Humperdinck? Prince Humperdinck hired Vizzini’s gang to frame a rival country for the abduction and murder of Princess Buttercup, thus smoothing the road to war. Westley (now a/k/a the Dread Pirate Roberts) hunted the kidnappers and blocked Vizzini from holding up his end of this deal. In Massachusetts, interference with someone else’s contractual or business relationship is not legally actionable unless the interferer acted with “improper means or motive.” There’s no improper motive here. True love is a passable motive. Not as good as mutton, lettuce, and tomato, but on the sunny side of the law. Westley’s means are more questionable. At first, Westley merely followed Vizzini and the gang. Then he drew blood from Inigo and knocked both Fezzik and Inigo unconscious. Still, the facts are on Westley’s side. Violence would typically count as “improper means,” but before Westley put his left hand to his sword, Inigo had already provided a useful disclosure that he was planning to kill him. So far, so defensible. But then, as Vezzik was poised to kill Buttercup, Westley counter-offered a battle of wits to the death. Now, Massachusetts jurisprudence does not offer many contractual interference cases centered on iocane powder. But I expect a jury would likely think that the man who out-dueled Inigo and out-wrestled Fezzik, yet left them both alive, could have rescued Buttercup without killing Vizzini. Quite plausibly, Westley wanted to kill the mastermind with a knife to his true love’s throat. Westley’s means are balanced precariously on lightning sand. That said, a person is liable for interfering with a contract only if he knows or should have known about it. Did Westley know Humperdinck was behind it? I think so. In the book, when Humperdinck introduces Buttercup to Florin, of the people gathered to see her, “three of them were planning to murder her,” and “in the farthest corner of the Great Square— —in the highest building in the land— —deep in the deepest shadow— —the man in black stood waiting.” We don’t know the details (that’s what depositions are for), but Westley did not just happen to see a boat with a captured princess. He knew there were dark plots—dark contracts—against her. But in the end: No, Westley is not liable for tortious interference. An agreement to murder a princess to incite a war is illegal, illegal contracts are void, and there is no liability for interfering with a void contract. For a similar reason, Prince Humperdinck can’t sue Vizzini (well, Vizzini’s estate) for breach of contract.
Sullivan & Worcester Tax Partner Amy Sheridan Elected to Firm's Management Committee
Boston, MA – International law firm Sullivan & Worcester announced today that Amy Sheridan, a partner in the Tax Practice, has been elected to the firm’s seven-person Management Committee. An industry leader regarding the tax implications of employee benefits and executive compensation, Amy has been recognized for her professional achievements by multiple legal trade outlets, including being named an “Employment Law Trailblazer” by the National Law Journal. “Amy has held a variety of leadership positions within the firm, and she brings valuable perspective to our Management Committee as we look to the future and continue maintaining the exceptional service our clients expect,” said David Nagle, Managing Partner at Sullivan. “She has a remarkable ability to dive deep into complex issues and fully appreciate the consequences of different outcomes, a quality her clients have extolled. I have no doubt that Amy will bring that same focus and thoughtful judgment to her work on the Management Committee.” Amy is experienced in designing, structuring and addressing documentation and compliance issues for compensation and benefit arrangements. She has broad expertise with regulatory and tax requirements related to welfare plans (including the Affordable Care Act and HIPAA privacy and security requirements), qualified and nonqualified retirement plans and IRAs. She has been recognized for her work in structuring novel and creative deferred compensation, bonus and phantom equity arrangements and is a thought leader on post-Dobbs legal developments and their impact on employee benefit plan arrangements.  A noted speaker on tax issues, Amy has numerous professional affiliations, including serving as an At-Large Member of the Boston Bar Association’s Tax Committee and as a former Co-Chair of its ERISA Committee. She is a lecturer at the Boston University School of Law’s Graduate Tax Program and was a Member of the Boston Compensation Advisory Board, the American Society of Pension Professionals & Actuaries and the New England Employee Benefits Council. In the broader business community, she was a member of the Greater Boston Chamber of Commerce’s Women’s Network Advisory Board and is former President of the Wellesley College Alumnae Association of Boston. Amy earned her J.D. at Harvard Law School and her LL.M. in Taxation from the Boston University School of Law. She attended Wellesley College for her undergraduate degree. About Sullivan Sullivan & Worcester (Sullivan) is a global, mid-sized law firm with lawyers in Boston, London, New York, Tel Aviv and Washington, D.C. Sullivan’s clients, including Fortune 500 companies, leading financial services firms and asset managers, boards of directors, real estate companies, and emerging businesses, rely on Sullivan’s ability to navigate complex legal and operational landscapes, the impeccable judgment of its lawyers, and its commitment to best‑in‑class client service.
Worker Harassment Cases Get ‘Tricky’ With Mentally Ill Patients
Erika Todd was quoted in the article "Worker Harassment Cases Get ‘Tricky’ With Mentally Ill Patients," published by Bloomberg Law on May 15, 2024. The article discusses the difficulties of treating worker harassment cases that involve third-party, non-employee mentally ill patients. "It is still theoretically possible to have a harassment claim that is based on a patient’s behavior,” Erika said. “But the bar is seen to be higher for how severe or how frequent the misbehavior must be before there’s a possible legal claim.” The decision also suggests that there’s a “certain amount of harassment or discrimination that you just have to put up with,” but not all health-care professionals “might be able to tolerate that,” she said.

Employment Counseling & Litigation

Our employment attorneys have years of experience advising clients on how to manage human resources most productively, with an emphasis on "preventive maintenance" and litigation avoidance. In addition to guiding company leaders on human resources matters, we also provide services to employees and executives seeking highly responsive and experienced legal guidance and advocacy.

We assist in formulating effective and dependable procedures for all phases of the employment relationship. At the hiring stage, we guide employers in complying with pay transparency laws and other evolving legal areas, prepare offer letters and employment contracts, and protect intellectual property through non-competition, non-solicitation, and confidentiality agreements.

We partner with our clients to create workplace policies that meet the needs of their workforces. We regularly assist clients in designing paid time off (including unlimited PTO) policies, policies for parental and disability needs, and policies for remote and hybrid work. We prepare anti-discrimination and retaliation policies, and we lead live trainings to educate workforces about appropriate workplace behavior.

Together with our compensation and benefits colleagues, we have the expertise to provide fast and cost-effective answers to “quick questions” and the depth to assist our clients with a wide variety of employment and tax-related issues including internal investigations, state law payroll compliance, assisting in exempt versus non-exempt employment classification for FLSA purposes, and advising on the often complex issue of employment versus independent contractor status.  We also routinely support clients in merger and acquisition transactions, including assisting with diligence, which often involves many of these just mentioned issues, and negotiation representations and covenants.

When especially delicate employment situations arise – including requests for religious or medical accommodation, allegations of harassment and discrimination, employee underperformance, and theft of intellectual property – we provide timely and savvy solutions.

When crisis and discord are unavoidable, we are poised to respond swiftly and decisively. We meet litigation threats with prompt risk assessment and experience-based strategy. Our practice group includes seasoned litigators who concentrate in employment-related disputes and adversary proceedings, including issues of unlawful termination, discrimination, breach of contract, covenants not to compete, compensation disputes, and benefit claims.

Our employment law team is backstopped by our compensation and benefits colleagues who are well versed in issues affecting employment law, such as helping to craft tax-efficient employment and severance arrangements, payroll reporting and withholding, and managing risk, including risk associated with Internal Revenue Code Sections 162(m), 280G, 4999, and 409A.

Employment & Benefits Practice Areas

Employment & Benefits

Compensation & Benefits Plan Design and Administration

Executive Compensation

ERISA Fiduciary

Viewpoints
All Viewpoints
Managing Performance, Managing Risk
When an employment relationship sours, the company’s performance management process can be a dangerous smoking gun—or its best defense. The thin line between unfairness and discrimination Employees do not have a statutory right to “fairness” in their performance reviews, workplace expectations, or discipline. If two employees violate the same policy, it is not automatically illegal to fire one and give the other a second chance. Yet unfairness is risky. Even when a company has a legitimate reason to take action, discrimination and retaliation must not influence the decision. If two employees consume alcohol at work, and the 30-year-old is given a second chance, but the 60-year-old is terminated, that employee may have a claim for age discrimination. If a retail company fires an employee for not making her sales goal, but there are other employees with worse numbers and the fired employee recently reported sexual harassment, the fired employee may have a claim for retaliation. One option is to maintain strict, clear rules. This can be a workable option for certain issues, such as illegal drug use at the workplace. But many performance issues require case-by-case decisions based on the full context. In those situations, a company can still reduce its legal risk by maintaining consistency where appropriate; thoughtfully deliberating about the legitimate business issues relevant to the situation; and committing itself to reaching decisions that reflect neutral business reasons alone. A solid approach from the very beginning helps to rebut allegations that the company acted because of bias or retaliation. Legal counsel can help guide an appropriate process. Respect for legal rights Employers should make sure that employees are judged for their performance, not their protected attributes or their protected actions. For example, an employee must not be criticized for working remotely if their employer previously approved that as a reasonable accommodation for their disability. An employee who took parental leave must not be criticized for taking that leave. Sometimes, an employee’s legal rights and their genuine performance issues intersect, such as when an employee has a disability that affects their work. Neither cancels the other, and legal counsel can help navigate these situations. Clarity and miscommunication Even when employers know they are providing neutral feedback, vague statements can be taken out of context and become legally dangerous. For example, a particular department might have one older worker within a younger team. A statement that the older worker should try to fit in better with the team culture could sound ageist. If there is a real, non-discriminatory problem—such as that the older worker is the only person on the team who does not answer questions from colleagues—the specific problem should be clearly identified. Supervisors and managers should be thoughtful whenever they are communicating with their team, whether in a verbal conversation, a formal performance review, or the many steps in between. When an employment relationship breaks down, even casual remarks are scrutinized, and vague or off-hand remarks can be taken as evidence of bias even if none was intended. For example, a statement that “Anne complains too much” might be referencing Anne’s whining about the slow printer, but if Anne has made a complaint of race discrimination, that statement could be understood another way. That casual comment could ultimately be presented to a jury, which will decide whose interpretation it believes. The flip side is that sometimes, managers use overly generous language (or give inflated numerical scores on performance reviews). The manager might be trying to be nice or simply trying to avoid confrontation. This is dangerous because it gives an employee false information about how the organization sees them. If that employee’s performance remains stable, and the employee is fired for underperformance before the next review cycle, the employee will understandably feel blindsided. The employee will also have evidence—created by the company itself—that directly undermines the company’s version of events. This could make the company vulnerable to an argument that it acted for a different, illegal reason. A truthful performance review gives an employee the opportunity to improve performance while avoiding a credibility crisis. If a tree falls in the forest, and no one sends a contemporaneous email, did it even happen? Annual performance reviews are important, but documenting performance issues should not be a once-a-year event. Emails, Teams messages, and Slack messages are all legitimate ways to discuss expectations and performance throughout the year. Verbal communications are also important, but they are vulnerable to different recollections. When a live conversation is preferred, consider a follow-up email to memorialize the substance. If an employee is terminated because of performance problems that arose between review cycles, but the performance issues were never documented in an email or other written message, the company could have a hard time proving that they were real. If an employee alleges that her firing was discriminatory, and the employer claims it was for legitimate reasons, the employee may argue that the so-called legitimate reasons are “pretextual.” If a judge or jury ultimately agrees that the employer’s stated reasons are pretextual, then an employee may win even without independent evidence of discrimination.[1] Similarly, an employee might take medical leave, support unionization, or take any other step that triggers anti-retaliation protections. Once those protections apply, an employee may argue that subsequent performance criticisms were not sincere, but retaliatory. In fact, in Massachusetts, when an employee takes paid family and medical leave, there is a presumption of retaliation for negative employment actions that happen during and even for 6 months after leave. Concerns that are documented before the employee announced an upcoming leave can be crucial in showing that the employer acted for legitimate reasons. By giving employees timely feedback as a standard practice, managers can reduce the risk that legitimate, performance-based decisions will be seen as retaliation.   Mid-year performance check-ins can involve a delicate balance between (1) providing necessary feedback so that the employee can understand expectations for success and (2) protecting the company in case the situation deteriorates. These two goals are compatible, but not identical. For example, a manager trying to be diplomatic might write: “I’d like you to take the lead in setting a collegial tone for the next meeting.” But if the backstory is that this very employee instigated a screaming match at the last meeting, that won’t be a very helpful piece of evidence. Conclusion Strong performance management limits legal risk while guiding employees toward success for themselves and for the organization. Legal counsel can help identify vulnerabilities and navigate any tension between risk exposure and business needs. Finally, employers should make sure that any discipline is consistent with any applicable employment contract or union agreement. [1] This is the law in Massachusetts, which is a “pretext-only” jurisdiction. Other jurisdictions apply a “pretext-plus” standard, which means a plaintiff employee cannot rely on pretext alone to win. This article is not legal advice. If you are interested in discussing any of these topics further, please contact a member of the Employment & Benefits Practice Group.
Lawsuits Are What Bring Us Together: "The Princess Bride" and the Law (Part 1)
First, a crucial clarification. While The Princess Bride (the wonderful movie) has the frame narrative of a grandfather who reads the book to his grandson, The Princess Bride (the wonderful book) has the frame narrative of a man whose father read it to him, and who wants to share it with his own son. The book is out of print, and the man sends his lawyer to a used bookstore during a blizzard. Although it’s always heartwarming when the lawyer is the hero of a favorite story… Clients: I esteem you; I cherish you; scavenger hunts during snowstorms are outside the scope of my litigation and employment practice. Please call the mergers and acquisitions team. Can Buttercup recover emotional distress damages from Ryan (a/k/a the Dread Pirate Roberts)? Promptly after Buttercup and Westley declared their mutual love, Westley was kidnapped by pirates and presumed murdered. Buttercup “never loved again” and “died that day.” In Massachusetts (and this article makes the common-sense assumption that Florin and the Commonwealth have largely identical legal systems), individuals can sometimes recover damages for their own emotional pain because of harm against a loved one. This type of claim depends on a close, preexisting relationship with the victim. Immediate family counts; Massachusetts is not very clear on which other relationships count. On the one hand, Westley had been working on Buttercup’s family farm for quite some time; they were in love, and he left to earn money for their marriage. On the other hand, for almost its entire length, their relationship consisted of demands for assorted manual tasks and repeated acquiescence. There might be some room for argument either way—at least at the time that Westley’s ship was captured. But these emotional distress claims are limited to certain relationships because of principles of foreseeability, and abstract questions about errands and “as you wish” became much less important when Westley begged for his life by putting the pirate on actual knowledge that true love was waiting for him at home. Once Ryan knew that Buttercup existed and had a vested interest in Westley’s well-being, Ryan couldn’t have been surprised that Buttercup was perturbed. Yet he spent the next three (3) years keeping Westley as a prisoner and threatening to kill him in the morning. The bigger issue for Buttercup’s lawsuit is that, to recover emotional distress damages, the loved one typically must have witnessed the harm or its immediate aftermath. By the time Buttercup was reunited with Westley, he wasn’t just not captured, but a thriving, rock-climbing small-business owner.  But Inigo could sue the Six-Fingered Man for murdering his father in front of him, right? Oh, definitely. Did Westley tortiously interfere with Vizzini’s business deal with Humperdinck? Prince Humperdinck hired Vizzini’s gang to frame a rival country for the abduction and murder of Princess Buttercup, thus smoothing the road to war. Westley (now a/k/a the Dread Pirate Roberts) hunted the kidnappers and blocked Vizzini from holding up his end of this deal. In Massachusetts, interference with someone else’s contractual or business relationship is not legally actionable unless the interferer acted with “improper means or motive.” There’s no improper motive here. True love is a passable motive. Not as good as mutton, lettuce, and tomato, but on the sunny side of the law. Westley’s means are more questionable. At first, Westley merely followed Vizzini and the gang. Then he drew blood from Inigo and knocked both Fezzik and Inigo unconscious. Still, the facts are on Westley’s side. Violence would typically count as “improper means,” but before Westley put his left hand to his sword, Inigo had already provided a useful disclosure that he was planning to kill him. So far, so defensible. But then, as Vezzik was poised to kill Buttercup, Westley counter-offered a battle of wits to the death. Now, Massachusetts jurisprudence does not offer many contractual interference cases centered on iocane powder. But I expect a jury would likely think that the man who out-dueled Inigo and out-wrestled Fezzik, yet left them both alive, could have rescued Buttercup without killing Vizzini. Quite plausibly, Westley wanted to kill the mastermind with a knife to his true love’s throat. Westley’s means are balanced precariously on lightning sand. That said, a person is liable for interfering with a contract only if he knows or should have known about it. Did Westley know Humperdinck was behind it? I think so. In the book, when Humperdinck introduces Buttercup to Florin, of the people gathered to see her, “three of them were planning to murder her,” and “in the farthest corner of the Great Square— —in the highest building in the land— —deep in the deepest shadow— —the man in black stood waiting.” We don’t know the details (that’s what depositions are for), but Westley did not just happen to see a boat with a captured princess. He knew there were dark plots—dark contracts—against her. But in the end: No, Westley is not liable for tortious interference. An agreement to murder a princess to incite a war is illegal, illegal contracts are void, and there is no liability for interfering with a void contract. For a similar reason, Prince Humperdinck can’t sue Vizzini (well, Vizzini’s estate) for breach of contract.
Sullivan & Worcester Tax Partner Amy Sheridan Elected to Firm's Management Committee
Boston, MA – International law firm Sullivan & Worcester announced today that Amy Sheridan, a partner in the Tax Practice, has been elected to the firm’s seven-person Management Committee. An industry leader regarding the tax implications of employee benefits and executive compensation, Amy has been recognized for her professional achievements by multiple legal trade outlets, including being named an “Employment Law Trailblazer” by the National Law Journal. “Amy has held a variety of leadership positions within the firm, and she brings valuable perspective to our Management Committee as we look to the future and continue maintaining the exceptional service our clients expect,” said David Nagle, Managing Partner at Sullivan. “She has a remarkable ability to dive deep into complex issues and fully appreciate the consequences of different outcomes, a quality her clients have extolled. I have no doubt that Amy will bring that same focus and thoughtful judgment to her work on the Management Committee.” Amy is experienced in designing, structuring and addressing documentation and compliance issues for compensation and benefit arrangements. She has broad expertise with regulatory and tax requirements related to welfare plans (including the Affordable Care Act and HIPAA privacy and security requirements), qualified and nonqualified retirement plans and IRAs. She has been recognized for her work in structuring novel and creative deferred compensation, bonus and phantom equity arrangements and is a thought leader on post-Dobbs legal developments and their impact on employee benefit plan arrangements.  A noted speaker on tax issues, Amy has numerous professional affiliations, including serving as an At-Large Member of the Boston Bar Association’s Tax Committee and as a former Co-Chair of its ERISA Committee. She is a lecturer at the Boston University School of Law’s Graduate Tax Program and was a Member of the Boston Compensation Advisory Board, the American Society of Pension Professionals & Actuaries and the New England Employee Benefits Council. In the broader business community, she was a member of the Greater Boston Chamber of Commerce’s Women’s Network Advisory Board and is former President of the Wellesley College Alumnae Association of Boston. Amy earned her J.D. at Harvard Law School and her LL.M. in Taxation from the Boston University School of Law. She attended Wellesley College for her undergraduate degree. About Sullivan Sullivan & Worcester (Sullivan) is a global, mid-sized law firm with lawyers in Boston, London, New York, Tel Aviv and Washington, D.C. Sullivan’s clients, including Fortune 500 companies, leading financial services firms and asset managers, boards of directors, real estate companies, and emerging businesses, rely on Sullivan’s ability to navigate complex legal and operational landscapes, the impeccable judgment of its lawyers, and its commitment to best‑in‑class client service.
Worker Harassment Cases Get ‘Tricky’ With Mentally Ill Patients
Erika Todd was quoted in the article "Worker Harassment Cases Get ‘Tricky’ With Mentally Ill Patients," published by Bloomberg Law on May 15, 2024. The article discusses the difficulties of treating worker harassment cases that involve third-party, non-employee mentally ill patients. "It is still theoretically possible to have a harassment claim that is based on a patient’s behavior,” Erika said. “But the bar is seen to be higher for how severe or how frequent the misbehavior must be before there’s a possible legal claim.” The decision also suggests that there’s a “certain amount of harassment or discrimination that you just have to put up with,” but not all health-care professionals “might be able to tolerate that,” she said.

Employment Counseling & Litigation