This website stores cookies on your computer. These cookies are used to improve your website experience and provide more personalized services to you, both on this website and through other media. To find out more about the cookies we use, see our Cookie Policy.
Accept Decline
mobile logo
  • Search
  • People
  • Capabilities
  • Global Reach
  • Insights
      NewsEventsViewpoints
  • About
      About UsDiversity, Equity and InclusionCommunity Engagement + Pro BonoCareersAlumni
  • ביוגרפיות
      ביוגרפיותישראל
logo
    People
    Capabilities
    Global Reach
    Insights +
    About +
    Eng +
Search

Michael S. Palmisciano

Partner
mpalmisciano@sullivanlaw.com
New York, NY: 212 660 3052

Portrait of Michael S. Palmisciano
default-marquee

Michael S. Palmisciano

Partner
Biography
Matters
Client Highlights
Viewpoints
News
Events
Biography
Matters
Client Highlights
Viewpoints
News
Events

May 10, 2024

–Client Alert

Supreme Court Extends Copyright Damages Period, Overrules Three-Year Lookback

Sullivan Client Alert

  • Share this page:

On May 9, 2024, in Warner Chappell Music, Inc. v. Nealy, the U.S. Supreme Court held that the Copyright Act permits a copyright owner to recover damages for infringing acts that occurred more than three years before bringing a claim, so long as the claim is timely filed. Although this decision brings clarity and resolves a circuit split on the damages assessment, the Court left unresolved the more fundamental question of when a copyright infringement claim accrues: when an infringing act occurs, or upon its discovery.

Background and Procedural History

The case involved a dispute between music producer Sherman Nealy, the founder of a company called Music Specialist, Inc., and the music publishing company Warner Chappell Music, Inc. Nealy alleged that, during a period in which Nealy was incarcerated, Nealy’s former business partner purported to license certain of Music Specialist’s songs to Warner Chappell. Warner Chappell subsequently licensed those songs for various purposes, including as a music sample used in the Flo Rida song, “In the Ayer.” Nealy asserted that he personally owned the copyrights in the Music Specialist works, and that Warner Chappell’s licensing activities infringed upon his rights. Nealy discovered the infringement in 2016 after his release from prison, and in 2018 sued Warner Chappell for copyright infringement in the Southern District of Florida.

The Copyright Act’s statute of limitations provides that a copyright owner must bring an infringement claim within three years of its accrual. U.S. circuit courts are divided as to whether a claim accrues when the infringing act occurs or upon the copyright owner’s discovery of the infringement.

In the District Court, Warner Chappell accepted the application of the discovery rule, but argued that Nealy could recover damages only for those infringements occurring in the past three years. The District Court agreed. Citing the Second Circuit decision Sohm v. Scholastic Inc., the District Court held that even in a timely filed claim, monetary relief is available only with respect to infringements in the three-year period prior to the commencement of the suit.

On appeal, the Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit reversed, rejecting the three-year damages bar.  Declining to follow the Second Circuit, the court instead adopted the Ninth Circuit’s view, holding that in a timely filed suit, a copyright owner is entitled to damages regardless of when the infringing acts occurred.

The Supreme Court Decision

In a 6-3 decision, the Supreme Court affirmed the Eleventh Circuit’s ruling, holding that where the discovery rule applies, there is no time limit to recovery of monetary damages in a timely filed copyright infringement action. Thus, a copyright owner that brings a timely claim is entitled to damages no matter when the infringement occurred. The majority criticized the Second Circuit’s approach as “self-defeating,” by, on the one hand, allowing a copyright owner to sue for infringing acts that occurred more than three years earlier, but on the other hand, prohibiting the copyright owner from recovering damages for those older infringements.

The Court expressly declined to decide on the appropriateness of the discovery rule, or “whether a copyright claim accrues when a plaintiff discovers or should have discovered an infringement, rather than when the infringement happened.” According to the majority, the issue of the discovery rule was not properly presented, as Warner Chappell did not challenge the Eleventh Circuit’s application of the rule.

Writing in dissent, Justice Gorsuch criticized the majority’s approach, stating that the Copyright Act “almost certainly does not tolerate a discovery rule.” Justice Gorsuch contended that, except in cases of fraud or concealment, the statute of limitations period should begin to run when the injury occurs, which is when the plaintiff is first entitled to file suit and obtain relief. Justice Gorsuch would have dismissed the case as improvidently granted.

Comments

In the near term, the Court’s decision in Warner Chappell could be a boon for copyright owners seeking to recover damages for past infringements in courts that apply the discovery rule, including in the Second Circuit. The ruling could materially increase the size of monetary damages recoveries. Yet, the Court has left unresolved the validity of the discovery rule. The dissenting opinion casts doubt on its long-term prospects and suggests that it is ripe for challenge. As Justice Gorsuch noted, this could render the Court’s decision a “dead letter.”

* * *

The case is Warner Chappell Music, Inc. v. Nealy, No. 22-1078 (U.S. May 9, 2024). The opinion is available here.

If you have any questions or would like to discuss this Client Alert, please contact one of the lawyers listed above or any member of Sullivan’s Copyright Group.

Related People

  • Michael Palmisciano
    Michael S. Palmisciano
  • Ida Vanto
    Ida J. Vanto

Capabilities

  • Intellectual Property
  • IP Litigation
  • Copyright
  • Trademarks
Biography Matters Client Highlights Viewpoints News Events

Featured

Events
Remediation of M&A REIT Targets: “To err is human; to forgive, divine”

Sarah Wellings and Connie Lee will present a Boston Bar Association (BBA) webinar, “Remediation of M&A REIT Targets: ‘To err is human; to forgive, divine,’” on Wednesday, December 9, from 12:00–1:00 p.m. Drawing on their recently updated white paper, Remediation of M&A REIT Targets, co-authored with Ameek Ashok Ponda, Sarah and Connie will discuss practical strategies for identifying, evaluating and remediating REIT qualification issues discovered during due diligence. The program will

Viewpoints
Employment Practices: Preventing the Avoidable Case

The first part of this series on litigation avoidance discussed the business case for preventing unnecessary litigation. Part two focused on startups and the steps startups can take to grow without unnecessarily creating legal disputes. This third installment zeroes in on employment law. Based on a recent report, 26,635 federal employment cases were filed in 2025, the highest number in the report’s ten-year dataset.[1] Many of these disputes could likely have

Viewpoints
Five Questions With Sullivan & Worcester Partner Richard Jones

Sullivan partner Richard Jones was featured in Bloomberg Tax’s "Five Questions With" series, which profiles prominent tax professionals and explores their perspectives on the practice of tax law. In the Q&A, Rich reflects on his pro bono work as special tax counsel in Gill v. Office of Personnel Management, a landmark constitutional challenge to the Defense of Marriage Act that helped pave the way for marriage equality nationwide. Rich also discusses pending

Viewpoints
John Graham Submits Comments to Treasury and IRS on Proposed Regulations for Racial Nondiscrimination in Private Schools

John Graham submitted comments to the U.S. Department of the Treasury and Internal Revenue Service in response to proposed regulations addressing racial nondiscrimination requirements for private schools under Section 501(c)(3). In his comments, Graham supports the longstanding rule that private schools engaging in racial discrimination do not qualify as charitable organizations under Section 501(c)(3), while urging Treasury and the IRS to clarify that remedial, inclusive race-conscious scholarship and outreach programs designed

Events
Is Digitalisation Closing the Unfunded Trade Finance Gap, or Making Things Worse?

Partner Geoffrey Wynne will moderate a panel discussion titled "Is Digitalisation Closing the Unfunded Trade Finance Gap, or Making Things Worse?" at Sullivan and Trade Treasury Payments’ (TTP) latest co-hosted Trade and Commodity Finance Breakfast Club, on Tuesday, 1 December, 2026 at The Lansdowne Club in London. Partner Matthew Cox will also participate as a panelist.  Trade finance still fails to reach many of the businesses that need it most, particularly

Events
Crane Data Money Fund University

John Hunt will speak on the panel discussion titled "European MMFs & Ultra-Short Funds" at the Crane Data Money Fund University, being held December 17-18, 2026, in Greenwich, CT. John will co-present with Peter Crane, President & Publisher of Crane Data.

News
Sullivan & Worcester Earns National and Regional Rankings in 2027 Best Law Firms®
Viewpoints
Personnel Records Law Changes the Terrain for New York Employers and Workers

A new law requires New York employers to give their employees access to their own personnel records upon request. This law (New York Labor Law Section 210-b) goes into effect November 8, 2026. What is a personnel record? The law defines a personnel record as a record that identifies an employee “to the extent that the record is used or has been used, or may affect or be used relative to that

News
Nancy Gillman Named to CREW New York's 2027 Board of Directors

Nancy Gillman, counsel in the firm's Real Estate Group, has been named to the 2027 Board of Directors of CREW New York. CREW New York is the local chapter of CREW Network, an international organization dedicated to advancing women in commercial real estate. Founded in 1978, the New York chapter brings together approximately 250 professionals from across the industry, providing opportunities for networking, professional development and business collaboration. Based in Sullivan's New

News
Media Coverage – Sullivan & Worcester's UK Export Finance Research Featured in Multiple Publications

Sullivan & Worcester's analysis of UK Export Finance (UKEF) support for technology companies was recently featured in The Morning Intelligence, Business Matters, Startups Magazine and Finance Chief Magazine. The firm's research, conducted in connection with International Trade Week 2026, found that UK digital and technology companies received just £39.9 million, or 0.08%, of approximately £50 billion in UKEF support over the past five years. The findings highlight the significant opportunity for

Events
Remediation of M&A REIT Targets: “To err is human; to forgive, divine”

Sarah Wellings and Connie Lee will present a Boston Bar Association (BBA) webinar, “Remediation of M&A REIT Targets: ‘To err is human; to forgive, divine,’” on Wednesday, December 9, from 12:00–1:00 p.m. Drawing on their recently updated white paper, Remediation of M&A REIT Targets, co-authored with Ameek Ashok Ponda, Sarah and Connie will discuss practical strategies for identifying, evaluating and remediating REIT qualification issues discovered during due diligence. The program will

Viewpoints
Employment Practices: Preventing the Avoidable Case

The first part of this series on litigation avoidance discussed the business case for preventing unnecessary litigation. Part two focused on startups and the steps startups can take to grow without unnecessarily creating legal disputes. This third installment zeroes in on employment law. Based on a recent report, 26,635 federal employment cases were filed in 2025, the highest number in the report’s ten-year dataset.[1] Many of these disputes could likely have

Viewpoints
Five Questions With Sullivan & Worcester Partner Richard Jones

Sullivan partner Richard Jones was featured in Bloomberg Tax’s "Five Questions With" series, which profiles prominent tax professionals and explores their perspectives on the practice of tax law. In the Q&A, Rich reflects on his pro bono work as special tax counsel in Gill v. Office of Personnel Management, a landmark constitutional challenge to the Defense of Marriage Act that helped pave the way for marriage equality nationwide. Rich also discusses pending

Viewpoints
John Graham Submits Comments to Treasury and IRS on Proposed Regulations for Racial Nondiscrimination in Private Schools

John Graham submitted comments to the U.S. Department of the Treasury and Internal Revenue Service in response to proposed regulations addressing racial nondiscrimination requirements for private schools under Section 501(c)(3). In his comments, Graham supports the longstanding rule that private schools engaging in racial discrimination do not qualify as charitable organizations under Section 501(c)(3), while urging Treasury and the IRS to clarify that remedial, inclusive race-conscious scholarship and outreach programs designed

Events
Is Digitalisation Closing the Unfunded Trade Finance Gap, or Making Things Worse?

Partner Geoffrey Wynne will moderate a panel discussion titled "Is Digitalisation Closing the Unfunded Trade Finance Gap, or Making Things Worse?" at Sullivan and Trade Treasury Payments’ (TTP) latest co-hosted Trade and Commodity Finance Breakfast Club, on Tuesday, 1 December, 2026 at The Lansdowne Club in London. Partner Matthew Cox will also participate as a panelist.  Trade finance still fails to reach many of the businesses that need it most, particularly

Events
Crane Data Money Fund University

John Hunt will speak on the panel discussion titled "European MMFs & Ultra-Short Funds" at the Crane Data Money Fund University, being held December 17-18, 2026, in Greenwich, CT. John will co-present with Peter Crane, President & Publisher of Crane Data.

Contact Us
Boston, MA
New York, NY
London, UK
Washington, DC
Tel Aviv, Israel
1251 Avenue of the Americas
19th Floor
New York, NY 10020
212 660 3000
More
brand-overlay
  • Contact Us
  • Terms of Use
  • Legal Notices
  • Cookie Policy
  • Privacy Policy
  • Attorney Advertising
  • Website Credits

Stay Connected

  • Alerts and Events
  • Sullivan Alumni

Careers

Join Our Team
Hebrew

© 2026 Sullivan & Worcester. All rights reserved.

This website does not track your personal or demographic information, only anonymous usage statistics. To ensure that you are not tracked, we have blocked all embedded content from third party sources like YouTube and SlideShare. Click "Accept Cookies" to enable third-party content. To learn more about our cookie policy, click here.
Accept CookiesNo Thanks