Biography

Ashley represents clients in all aspects of commercial real estate transactions, leasing, and land use and development. She advises developers, affordable housing developers, real estate investment trusts and institutional clients on acquisitions and dispositions, development approvals, zoning and permitting, and title issues.

Her land use and development practice includes guiding clients through the permitting and entitlement process for multifamily, affordable housing, office, life sciences and institutional projects. She has experience with adaptive reuse, air rights, planned development areas, institutional master plans, and various Massachusetts development programs, including Chapters 40B, 40R, 121A and 121B. Ashley has represented clients before zoning boards, planning boards, licensing boards, city councils and other local and state agencies in Boston and throughout Eastern Massachusetts.

Prior to joining Sullivan, Ashley was a commercial real estate associate at a regional law firm in Boston and worked for a nonprofit community development financial institution. She also served as a Legal Fellow to the Honorable Robert B. Foster of the Massachusetts Land Court.

Ashley graduated magna cum laude from New York University with a degree in Urban Design and Architectural Studies and received her law degree from Boston University School of Law.

She is a member of the City of Cambridge Planning Board.

Education
  • Boston University School of Law (J.D.)
  • New York University (B.A., magna cum laude)
Bar & Court Admissions
  • Massachusetts
Professional Qualifications
  • Real Estate Bar Association, Member
  • Boston Bar Association, Member
  • Asian American Lawyers Association of Massachusetts, Committee Member
  • Urban Land Institute, Member
Awards & Honors
  • Best Lawyers in America® Ones to Watch (2023-2027)
  • "Up & Coming Lawyer," Massachusetts Lawyers Weekly (2023)
  • "Rising Star," Massachusetts Super Lawyers (2024-2026)
  • Recommended by The Legal 500 U.S. (2025-2026)
Community Engagement
  • City of Cambridge Planning Board, Member
  • Taiwanese American Professionals - Boston Chapter, Former Board Member
Languages
  • Mandarin
Viewpoints
All Viewpoints
Massachusetts SJC Upholds MBTA Communities Act Multifamily Zoning Mandate
On Friday, September 18, 2026, the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court (the “SJC”) affirmed the dismissal of the Town of Marshfield’s challenge to the MBTA Communities Act (the “Act” or “Section 3A”).[1] The decision confirms that covered municipalities must adopt and maintain zoning that permits multifamily housing as of right in at least one district. It also rejects Marshfield’s four principal theories for avoiding that obligation, which are explored in more detail below. Notably, the SJC rejected Marshfield’s claim that the Act improperly imposes an unlawful mandatory direct service or cost obligation on cities and towns. For multifamily developers and lenders, the immediate takeaway is that there is now increased legal certainty around the need for all municipalities subject to the MBTA Communities Act to adopt and maintain zoning that permits multifamily development as of right. Those communities that have continued to hold out from compliance and that have challenged the state’s role in zoning have lost another challenge to the MBTA Communities Act. The SJC made it clear that municipalities must comply with the requirements of the Act and that the Act is a valid law addressing the statewide housing shortage. The MBTA Communities Act: What it Does Enacted in 2021, the MBTA Communities Act requires each “MBTA community”[2] to have at least one zoning district of reasonable size in which multifamily housing is permitted without age restrictions and suitable for families with children,[3] without a special permit or other discretionary zoning approval.[4] The statute generally requires the district to have a minimum gross density of 15 units per acre and, where applicable, location within one-half mile of a commuter rail station, subway station, ferry terminal, or bus station. Importantly, the statute is only a zoning mandate and does not compel landowners to construct multifamily housing or any specified number of units. The implementing regulations promulgated by the Executive Office of Housing and Livable Communities (“EOHLC”)[5] use community categories, minimum land area, unit-capacity calculations, density, location, and other criteria to determine compliance. Non-compliant communities are ineligible for certain state funding programs, including the Housing Choice Initiative, Local Capital Projects Fund, MassWorks infrastructure program, and HousingWorks infrastructure program.[6] The SJC previously confirmed in Attorney General v. Milton[7] that the Act imposes an enforceable, mandatory duty upon affected communities to comply. How the Marshfield Dispute Arose Marshfield, an MBTA community, held special town meetings on April 22 and December 16, 2024 to consider zoning amendments intended to bring the town into compliance with the Act, and both proposals failed. On February 10, 2025, the Select Board unanimously voted not to approve an interim action plan to help bring Marshfield into compliance with the Act. EOHLC then notified Marshfield that it was non-compliant and risked losing state grant funding. Marshfield and its Select Board sued the Commonwealth and EOHLC in Superior Court arguing that the Act and its regulations: (1) constituted an unfunded local mandate; (2) infringed upon the voting rights of town meeting voters; (3) violated the Home Rule Amendment to the Massachusetts Constitution; and (4) conflicted with other zoning laws that govern local adoption of zoning ordinances. The Superior Court dismissed Marshfield’s suit, and the SJC accepted direct appellate review. The SJC’s Decision  Marshfield’s Local Mandate Argument. Under Massachusetts’ Local Mandate Law, state laws and regulations adopted after 1980 (with some exceptions) that impose a mandatory direct service or cost obligation upon municipalities can only be binding in a municipality if the law or regulation has been accepted by that municipality (either expressly or implicitly).[8] However, costs attributable to incidental administrative expenses or the municipality’s voluntary choices about how to comply with a law do not fall within the definition of “direct service[s] or cost obligation[s]” prohibited by the Local Mandate Law. Marshfield argued that the costs of evaluating and drafting proposed zoning bylaws, presenting them at town meetings, and anticipated future expenses required by the MBTA Communities Act violates the Local Mandate Law. The SJC rejected Marshfield’s local mandate argument, holding that the only costs of compliance with the Act alleged by Marshfield (i) constituted incidental administrative expenses, (ii) were voluntary choices of the municipality, or (iii) were too speculative. Importantly, the SJC did not hold that every possible cost associated with Section 3A compliance is categorically outside § 27C.  Marshfield’s argument regarding violation of voters’ constitutional rights. As noted above, the second argument made by Marshfield was that the Act violates the voting rights of its citizens. However, the SJC held that Marshfield, as a political subdivision of the Commonwealth, generally may not challenge a state law by asserting state constitutional protections belonging to persons independent of the Commonwealth. Since the case was brought by the town and the members of its Select Board in their official capacities and alleged no personal injury, the SJC determined that they lacked standing to assert the claimed voting rights violations on behalf of the town’s voters.  Marshfield’s argument that the Act violates the Home Rule Amendment. In its decision, the SJC explained that the Home Rule Amendment[9] preserves municipal authority over local matters, but does not prevent the Legislature from imposing substantive requirements through a valid general law addressing a statewide concern. Since housing supply is not confined to any one municipality, the SJC concluded that the Act falls within the Legislature’s retained authority and does not violate the Home Rule Amendment.  Marshfield’s argument that the Act conflicts with ordinary zoning-adoption procedures. Marshfield also argued that the Act conflicts with M.G.L. c. 40A, § 5 which governs the adoption of zoning ordinances by municipalities. However, the SJC determined that Section 5 continues to govern the local procedure for adopting and amending zoning, whereas the Act imposes a substantive state-law requirement on the zoning that results. City councils and town meeting voters remain free to debate, amend, approve, or reject a proposal, but their authority does not include exempting the municipality from valid state law. A vote rejecting compliant zoning, therefore, results in municipal non-compliance; it does not invalidate Section 3A or create a statutory conflict. Practical Implications Greater durability of the statewide zoning framework. The decision removes the specific legal theories Marshfield advanced as a basis for opting out and reinforces prior authority that Section 3A is mandatory. Cities and towns, therefore, must adopt zoning and seek EOHLC approval to avoid non-compliance. Zoning capacity is not project entitlement. A compliant district must allow multifamily housing as of right, but site-plan review may still regulate layout, access, design, and screening so long as it does not operate as a disguised discretionary denial or make a compliant project impractical. Other generally applicable permitting regimes remain relevant. Municipal implementation still matters. The value of Section 3A zoning to a development project will vary by location, dimensional standards, parking requirements, parcel configuration, infrastructure, wetlands, Title 5 constraints, and market conditions. Developers should analyze the adopted bylaw or ordinance, zoning map, and any later municipal amendments or practices rather than relying solely on a community’s published compliance status. Compliance is ongoing. Under 760 CMR 72.10, EOHLC may rescind a compliance determination or require changes if a municipality materially alters the district or fails to issue permits for qualifying as-of-right development. Project teams should monitor post-compliance zoning amendments, local rules, and permitting conduct that could affect the district. Financing diligence should remain site-specific. Lenders may take additional comfort from the SJC’s validation of the statutory framework. However, as always, in making lending decisions and considering construction draw requests for any particular project, lenders should continue to be mindful of current zoning, building and other entitlement compliance, the status of non-zoning permits, etc. Non-compliant municipalities remain a live enforcement and timing risk. The case confirms that a failed local vote does not excuse non-compliance but does not directly address the remedy for continued refusal of a municipality to comply. Developers pursuing sites in a non-compliant community should account for continued uncertainty until compliant zoning is adopted, approved, and applied in practice.  The unfunded-mandate issue is narrowed, not erased. Because the SJC expressly declined to rule categorically on all compliance costs, other municipalities may try to make future arguments that specific costs associated with the Act constitute an unlawful unfunded mandate. This case nevertheless sets a demanding standard and makes clear that generalized costs of the type described by Marshfield do not fall within the unfunded mandate prohibition. Conclusion Marshfield is a significant affirmation of the Commonwealth’s authority to require qualifying multifamily zoning in MBTA communities. For developers and lenders, it strengthens confidence that Section 3A districts rest on a valid statewide mandate and that municipalities cannot rely on ordinary local voting procedures, home rule, generalized cost allegations, or third-party constitutional claims to opt out. Municipalities must continue to take steps to ensure compliance with the Act. Sullivan’s Real Estate, Permitting & Land Use, and Real Estate Finance teams are monitoring implementation of the MBTA Communities Act and related enforcement and are available to assist with zoning, permitting, development, and financing questions. [1] Town of Marshfield v. Commonwealth, SJC-13840, slip op. (Sept. 18, 2026). [2] MBTA communities are defined as municipalities that host MBTA service, “served communities” that abut a host municipality, and certain other municipalities that have become subject to the Act through M.G.L. c. 161A, § 6. [3] M.G.L. c. 40A, § 3A(a)(1). [4] M.G.L. c. 40A, § 1A. The EOHLC regulations, however, permit site-plan review and certain other constraints. [5] 760 CMR 72.00. [6] M.G.L. c. 40A, § 3A(a)(2). [7] Attorney General v. Milton, 495 Mass. 183 (2025). [8] M.G.L. c. 29, § 27(c). [9] Article LXXXIX of the Amendments to the Massachusetts Constitution.
Governor Signs Economic Development and Clean Energy Bills: Key Insights
On November 20, 2024, Massachusetts Governor Maura Healey signed a $3.9 billon economic development bill, known as the Mass Leads Act (H 5100), and also signed the Climate and Clean Energy Siting Law (S 2967). These laws are aimed at stimulating economic growth, promoting real estate development, advancing clean energy infrastructure, and accelerating the permitting process for energy projects in Massachusetts. The Mass Leads Act includes several provisions designed to improve the permitting process such as the Permit Extension Act, the creation of a State Permitting Regulatory Office, and protections for municipal zoning permits. Alongside the Mass Leads Act, the Climate and Clean Energy Siting Law introduces comprehensive reform to fast-track Massachusetts’ transition to clean energy. A key component of the Climate and Clean Energy Siting Law is streamlining the permitting process by having the Energy Facilities Siting Board grant permits for large energy projects while municipalities grant permits for smaller ones. This law also includes initiatives to promote energy storage, renewable energy, and electric vehicle infrastructure. Key Provisions of The Mass Leads Act The Mass Leads Act has key provisions to advance economic growth, make the permitting process more efficient, and drive investment in essential industries such as data centers, life sciences, and clean energy.  Included in the Mass Leads Act is the Permit Extension Act, which extends any permit, certificate, order (however, excluding enforcement orders), and license, determination, variance, waiver, building permit, or other such approval granted by a municipal, regional, or state governmental entity, for the use or development of real property, as well as any environmental approval in effect or in existence between January 1, 2023, and January 1, 2025, for a two-year period after the lawful term of the approval. The extension, however, does not apply to permits issued by federal agencies or subject to federal law.  Nor does it apply to certain specified approvals by the Massachusetts Division of Fisheries and Wildlife, the Department of Energy Resources, the Department of Transportation or the MBTA. Additionally, the Mass Leads Act includes an Act to Safeguard Municipal Permitting, which protects an owner or developer from needing to comply with subsequent zoning changes if the use or construction commences under a special permit or site plan approval within three (3) years after issuance of the special permit or site plan approval. Under prior law, there was only a one (1) year protection from subsequent zoning changes for special permits, and no protection for site plan approvals. The Mass Leads Act also creates a State Permit Regulatory Office under the Executive Office of Economic Development. The director of the Permit Regulatory Office will, among other things, work with other state agencies to expedite the process of obtaining state licenses, permits, and other approvals, establish a State Permit Ombudsman to assist new and expanding businesses, and review or deny municipal priority development site proposals made pursuant to M.G.L. c. 43D. The Act also establishes a separate Regulatory Ombudsman within the Permit Regulatory Office who will help businesses navigate compliance with state regulations and train state agencies on how to identify and lessen the impacts of regulation on small businesses. Key Provisions of the Climate and Clean Energy Siting Law The Climate and Clean Energy Siting Law introduces significant updates designed to streamline permitting processes and establish new statewide policies for clean energy projects. This law focuses on streamlining the permitting review process for clean energy projects, including energy storage projects, by consolidating all state, local, and regional, permits into a single master permit. Under this new system, the State Energy Facilities Siting Board will review all large clean energy projects (more than 25 megawatts of power or 100 megawatts of storage) with a decision required within 15 months from submission of an application. Municipalities will continue to oversee smaller projects, with permits to be issued or rejected within 12 months. If these deadlines are not met the application will be automatically approved, but the legislature may reassess the process if too many applications receive automatic approval. Besides streamlining the process, the law creates a new division of Clean Energy Siting and Permitting within the Department of Energy Resources. The new division is tasked with developing requirements for siting and permitting of small energy projects by local governments. These requirements will standardize the review and approval processes used by municipalities across the Commonwealth. This law lays the groundwork for important statewide policies focused on clean energy procurement and renewable energy sources. It broadens the scope of “clean energy” technologies to include nuclear fission and carbon reducing technologies, while coordinating with neighboring New England states to secure long term contracts with nuclear plants. The new law mandates a significant increase of energy storage capacity targeting 5,000 megawatt hours by 2030 to support renewable energy sources such as wind and solar. The law also simplifies and removes a number of barriers to the installation of electric vehicle charging infrastructure, including providing for broader use of pole-mounted electric vehicle chargers, removal of barriers to use of EV charging infrastructure that may otherwise be imposed by historic district commissions or neighborhood or homeowner associations. The law also codifies a definition of “public service corporations” as it relates to zoning exemptions that may be granted by the Department of Public Utilities or the Energy Facilities Siting Board. Under the legislation, a “public service corporation” refers to any corporation or entity qualified to do business in the Commonwealth that owns, operates, or plans to operate assets or facilities providing essential services such as gas, telecommunication, cable, water, or other similar services to the public. Under prior law, “public service corporations” were not defined by statute, and an unnecessary amount of documentation and analysis needed to be provided in administrative proceedings to establish what, in most cases, was an obvious determination. Lastly, the new climate legislation temporarily expands the jurisdiction of the Land Court’s specialized permit session to include renewable energy and energy storage projects. Given the Court’s expertise with land use permitting, this change should expedite the permitting process and ensure more efficient resolution for these projects in advance of the broader changes to the permitting processes. The approval of the Mass Leads Act and the Climate and Clean Energy Siting Law represents a pivotal step in boosting the Massachusetts economy, supporting continued real estate development, and advancing its climate and clean energy goals. If you have any questions or would like to discuss this Client Alert, please contact Greg Sampson, or any member of Sullivan’s Permitting and Land Use team.
44 Sullivan & Worcester Lawyers Selected as “Best Lawyers” Award Recipients
Boston, MA – Sullivan & Worcester today announced that 44 lawyers were recognized in the 2027 edition of Best Lawyers in America®. 40 of the firm’s lawyers in Boston, New York and Washington, D.C. were selected as “Best Lawyers in America®,” and four Sullivan lawyers were recognized as “Ones to Watch” in the U.S. Best Lawyers in America® The firm’s 2027 Best Lawyers in Boston include Victor Baltera (Environmental Law, Real Estate Law); Howard Berkenblit (Corporate Governance Law, Corporate Law); Harvey Bines (Corporate Compliance Law, Corporate Governance Law, Corporate Law); Ashley Brooks (Real Estate Law); Joel Carpenter (Tax Law); Henry Comstock, Jr. (Trusts and Estates); Christopher Curtis (Tax Law); Patrick Dinardo (Bankruptcy and Creditor Debtor Rights / Insolvency and Reorganization Law, Litigation - Bankruptcy); John Graham (Nonprofit / Charities Law, Tax Law); David Guadagnoli (Employee Benefits (ERISA) Law, Tax Law); Warren Heilbronner (Real Estate Law); Zachary Hyde (Patent Law); Richard Jones (Tax Law); Karen Kepler (Real Estate Law); Caroline Kupiec (Tax Law); Thomas Meyers (Patent Law); Lisa Mingolla (Trusts and Estates); Louis Monti (Real Estate Law); Cornelius Murray III (Trusts and Estates); David Nagle (Litigation and Controversy - Tax, Tax Law); Ameek Ashok Ponda (Tax Law); Gregory Sampson (Environmental Law, Land Use and Zoning Law, Real Estate Law); Lewis Segall (Corporate Law, Mergers and Acquisitions Law); Amy Sheridan (Employee Benefits (ERISA) Law, Tax Law); Laura Steinberg (Commercial Litigation); John Steiner (Real Estate Law); Douglas Stransky (Tax Law); Sarah Wellings (Tax Law); and Amy Zuccarello (Bankruptcy and Creditor Debtor Rights / Insolvency and Reorganization Law, Litigation - Bankruptcy). Sullivan’s 2027 Best Lawyers in Washington, D.C. include John Chilton (Mutual Funds Law); Cameron Cosby (Tax Law); Nicole Crum (Mutual Funds Law); David Leahy (Mutual Funds Law); David Mahaffey (Mutual Funds Law, Securities Regulation); and Stephanie Monaco (Corporate Law, Mutual Funds Law, Private Funds / Hedge Funds Law, Securities Regulation). The firm’s 2027 Best Lawyers in New York include Carole Bass (Trusts and Estates); J. Truman Bidwell, Jr. (Corporate Law); Domenick Pugliese (Mutual Funds Law); Constantine Ralli (Trusts and Estates); and Marc Stern (Trusts and Estates). Best Lawyers: Ones to Watch Awardees Best Lawyers awards this recognition to attorneys who are earlier in their careers for their outstanding professional excellence in private practice in the United States. Sullivan’s lawyers earning this award include Alexander Gansebom (Corporate Governance and Compliance Law, Corporate Law, Health Care Law, Mergers and Acquisitions Law, Real Estate Law); Emily Goldschmidt (Corporate Law); Ryan Rosenblatt (Commercial Litigation); and Ashley Tan (Real Estate Law). Best Lawyers Selection Methodology Recognition by Best Lawyers in America® is based on a peer review process designed to capture the consensus opinion of leading lawyers about the professional abilities of their colleagues within the same geographical and legal practice areas. About Sullivan Sullivan & Worcester (Sullivan) is a premier, AmLaw 200 international law firm with lawyers in Boston, London, New York, Tel Aviv and Washington, D.C. Sullivan’s clients, including Fortune 500 companies, leading financial services firms and asset managers, boards of directors, real estate companies, and emerging businesses, rely on Sullivan’s ability to navigate complex legal and operational landscapes, the impeccable judgment of its lawyers, and its commitment to best-in-class client service.
Sullivan Represents Fattal Hotel Group in Acquisition of The Blakely Hotel in Midtown Manhattan
Sullivan & Worcester represented Fattal Hotel Group, owner and operator of 329 hotels across 22 countries and based in Tel Aviv, in its acquisition and financing of The Blakely Hotel in Midtown Manhattan. The acquisition marks the client's first hotel investment in the United States and is a milestone in its evolution from a leading European hospitality operator into a global hotel group. The acquisition was completed on July 7, 2026. The Sullivan team included Ashley Brooks, Tamir Chagal, Oded Har-Even, Gerry Silver, John Steiner, Nancy Gillman and Ashley Tan. Read more about the transaction here.  

Ashley Tan

Ashley represents clients in all aspects of commercial real estate transactions, leasing, and land use and development. She advises developers, affordable housing developers, real estate investment trusts and institutional clients on acquisitions and dispositions, development approvals, zoning and permitting, and title issues.

Her land use and development practice includes guiding clients through the permitting and entitlement process for multifamily, affordable housing, office, life sciences and institutional projects. She has experience with adaptive reuse, air rights, planned development areas, institutional master plans, and various Massachusetts development programs, including Chapters 40B, 40R, 121A and 121B. Ashley has represented clients before zoning boards, planning boards, licensing boards, city councils and other local and state agencies in Boston and throughout Eastern Massachusetts.

Prior to joining Sullivan, Ashley was a commercial real estate associate at a regional law firm in Boston and worked for a nonprofit community development financial institution. She also served as a Legal Fellow to the Honorable Robert B. Foster of the Massachusetts Land Court.

Ashley graduated magna cum laude from New York University with a degree in Urban Design and Architectural Studies and received her law degree from Boston University School of Law.

She is a member of the City of Cambridge Planning Board.

Viewpoints
All Viewpoints
Massachusetts SJC Upholds MBTA Communities Act Multifamily Zoning Mandate
On Friday, September 18, 2026, the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court (the “SJC”) affirmed the dismissal of the Town of Marshfield’s challenge to the MBTA Communities Act (the “Act” or “Section 3A”).[1] The decision confirms that covered municipalities must adopt and maintain zoning that permits multifamily housing as of right in at least one district. It also rejects Marshfield’s four principal theories for avoiding that obligation, which are explored in more detail below. Notably, the SJC rejected Marshfield’s claim that the Act improperly imposes an unlawful mandatory direct service or cost obligation on cities and towns. For multifamily developers and lenders, the immediate takeaway is that there is now increased legal certainty around the need for all municipalities subject to the MBTA Communities Act to adopt and maintain zoning that permits multifamily development as of right. Those communities that have continued to hold out from compliance and that have challenged the state’s role in zoning have lost another challenge to the MBTA Communities Act. The SJC made it clear that municipalities must comply with the requirements of the Act and that the Act is a valid law addressing the statewide housing shortage. The MBTA Communities Act: What it Does Enacted in 2021, the MBTA Communities Act requires each “MBTA community”[2] to have at least one zoning district of reasonable size in which multifamily housing is permitted without age restrictions and suitable for families with children,[3] without a special permit or other discretionary zoning approval.[4] The statute generally requires the district to have a minimum gross density of 15 units per acre and, where applicable, location within one-half mile of a commuter rail station, subway station, ferry terminal, or bus station. Importantly, the statute is only a zoning mandate and does not compel landowners to construct multifamily housing or any specified number of units. The implementing regulations promulgated by the Executive Office of Housing and Livable Communities (“EOHLC”)[5] use community categories, minimum land area, unit-capacity calculations, density, location, and other criteria to determine compliance. Non-compliant communities are ineligible for certain state funding programs, including the Housing Choice Initiative, Local Capital Projects Fund, MassWorks infrastructure program, and HousingWorks infrastructure program.[6] The SJC previously confirmed in Attorney General v. Milton[7] that the Act imposes an enforceable, mandatory duty upon affected communities to comply. How the Marshfield Dispute Arose Marshfield, an MBTA community, held special town meetings on April 22 and December 16, 2024 to consider zoning amendments intended to bring the town into compliance with the Act, and both proposals failed. On February 10, 2025, the Select Board unanimously voted not to approve an interim action plan to help bring Marshfield into compliance with the Act. EOHLC then notified Marshfield that it was non-compliant and risked losing state grant funding. Marshfield and its Select Board sued the Commonwealth and EOHLC in Superior Court arguing that the Act and its regulations: (1) constituted an unfunded local mandate; (2) infringed upon the voting rights of town meeting voters; (3) violated the Home Rule Amendment to the Massachusetts Constitution; and (4) conflicted with other zoning laws that govern local adoption of zoning ordinances. The Superior Court dismissed Marshfield’s suit, and the SJC accepted direct appellate review. The SJC’s Decision  Marshfield’s Local Mandate Argument. Under Massachusetts’ Local Mandate Law, state laws and regulations adopted after 1980 (with some exceptions) that impose a mandatory direct service or cost obligation upon municipalities can only be binding in a municipality if the law or regulation has been accepted by that municipality (either expressly or implicitly).[8] However, costs attributable to incidental administrative expenses or the municipality’s voluntary choices about how to comply with a law do not fall within the definition of “direct service[s] or cost obligation[s]” prohibited by the Local Mandate Law. Marshfield argued that the costs of evaluating and drafting proposed zoning bylaws, presenting them at town meetings, and anticipated future expenses required by the MBTA Communities Act violates the Local Mandate Law. The SJC rejected Marshfield’s local mandate argument, holding that the only costs of compliance with the Act alleged by Marshfield (i) constituted incidental administrative expenses, (ii) were voluntary choices of the municipality, or (iii) were too speculative. Importantly, the SJC did not hold that every possible cost associated with Section 3A compliance is categorically outside § 27C.  Marshfield’s argument regarding violation of voters’ constitutional rights. As noted above, the second argument made by Marshfield was that the Act violates the voting rights of its citizens. However, the SJC held that Marshfield, as a political subdivision of the Commonwealth, generally may not challenge a state law by asserting state constitutional protections belonging to persons independent of the Commonwealth. Since the case was brought by the town and the members of its Select Board in their official capacities and alleged no personal injury, the SJC determined that they lacked standing to assert the claimed voting rights violations on behalf of the town’s voters.  Marshfield’s argument that the Act violates the Home Rule Amendment. In its decision, the SJC explained that the Home Rule Amendment[9] preserves municipal authority over local matters, but does not prevent the Legislature from imposing substantive requirements through a valid general law addressing a statewide concern. Since housing supply is not confined to any one municipality, the SJC concluded that the Act falls within the Legislature’s retained authority and does not violate the Home Rule Amendment.  Marshfield’s argument that the Act conflicts with ordinary zoning-adoption procedures. Marshfield also argued that the Act conflicts with M.G.L. c. 40A, § 5 which governs the adoption of zoning ordinances by municipalities. However, the SJC determined that Section 5 continues to govern the local procedure for adopting and amending zoning, whereas the Act imposes a substantive state-law requirement on the zoning that results. City councils and town meeting voters remain free to debate, amend, approve, or reject a proposal, but their authority does not include exempting the municipality from valid state law. A vote rejecting compliant zoning, therefore, results in municipal non-compliance; it does not invalidate Section 3A or create a statutory conflict. Practical Implications Greater durability of the statewide zoning framework. The decision removes the specific legal theories Marshfield advanced as a basis for opting out and reinforces prior authority that Section 3A is mandatory. Cities and towns, therefore, must adopt zoning and seek EOHLC approval to avoid non-compliance. Zoning capacity is not project entitlement. A compliant district must allow multifamily housing as of right, but site-plan review may still regulate layout, access, design, and screening so long as it does not operate as a disguised discretionary denial or make a compliant project impractical. Other generally applicable permitting regimes remain relevant. Municipal implementation still matters. The value of Section 3A zoning to a development project will vary by location, dimensional standards, parking requirements, parcel configuration, infrastructure, wetlands, Title 5 constraints, and market conditions. Developers should analyze the adopted bylaw or ordinance, zoning map, and any later municipal amendments or practices rather than relying solely on a community’s published compliance status. Compliance is ongoing. Under 760 CMR 72.10, EOHLC may rescind a compliance determination or require changes if a municipality materially alters the district or fails to issue permits for qualifying as-of-right development. Project teams should monitor post-compliance zoning amendments, local rules, and permitting conduct that could affect the district. Financing diligence should remain site-specific. Lenders may take additional comfort from the SJC’s validation of the statutory framework. However, as always, in making lending decisions and considering construction draw requests for any particular project, lenders should continue to be mindful of current zoning, building and other entitlement compliance, the status of non-zoning permits, etc. Non-compliant municipalities remain a live enforcement and timing risk. The case confirms that a failed local vote does not excuse non-compliance but does not directly address the remedy for continued refusal of a municipality to comply. Developers pursuing sites in a non-compliant community should account for continued uncertainty until compliant zoning is adopted, approved, and applied in practice.  The unfunded-mandate issue is narrowed, not erased. Because the SJC expressly declined to rule categorically on all compliance costs, other municipalities may try to make future arguments that specific costs associated with the Act constitute an unlawful unfunded mandate. This case nevertheless sets a demanding standard and makes clear that generalized costs of the type described by Marshfield do not fall within the unfunded mandate prohibition. Conclusion Marshfield is a significant affirmation of the Commonwealth’s authority to require qualifying multifamily zoning in MBTA communities. For developers and lenders, it strengthens confidence that Section 3A districts rest on a valid statewide mandate and that municipalities cannot rely on ordinary local voting procedures, home rule, generalized cost allegations, or third-party constitutional claims to opt out. Municipalities must continue to take steps to ensure compliance with the Act. Sullivan’s Real Estate, Permitting & Land Use, and Real Estate Finance teams are monitoring implementation of the MBTA Communities Act and related enforcement and are available to assist with zoning, permitting, development, and financing questions. [1] Town of Marshfield v. Commonwealth, SJC-13840, slip op. (Sept. 18, 2026). [2] MBTA communities are defined as municipalities that host MBTA service, “served communities” that abut a host municipality, and certain other municipalities that have become subject to the Act through M.G.L. c. 161A, § 6. [3] M.G.L. c. 40A, § 3A(a)(1). [4] M.G.L. c. 40A, § 1A. The EOHLC regulations, however, permit site-plan review and certain other constraints. [5] 760 CMR 72.00. [6] M.G.L. c. 40A, § 3A(a)(2). [7] Attorney General v. Milton, 495 Mass. 183 (2025). [8] M.G.L. c. 29, § 27(c). [9] Article LXXXIX of the Amendments to the Massachusetts Constitution.
Governor Signs Economic Development and Clean Energy Bills: Key Insights
On November 20, 2024, Massachusetts Governor Maura Healey signed a $3.9 billon economic development bill, known as the Mass Leads Act (H 5100), and also signed the Climate and Clean Energy Siting Law (S 2967). These laws are aimed at stimulating economic growth, promoting real estate development, advancing clean energy infrastructure, and accelerating the permitting process for energy projects in Massachusetts. The Mass Leads Act includes several provisions designed to improve the permitting process such as the Permit Extension Act, the creation of a State Permitting Regulatory Office, and protections for municipal zoning permits. Alongside the Mass Leads Act, the Climate and Clean Energy Siting Law introduces comprehensive reform to fast-track Massachusetts’ transition to clean energy. A key component of the Climate and Clean Energy Siting Law is streamlining the permitting process by having the Energy Facilities Siting Board grant permits for large energy projects while municipalities grant permits for smaller ones. This law also includes initiatives to promote energy storage, renewable energy, and electric vehicle infrastructure. Key Provisions of The Mass Leads Act The Mass Leads Act has key provisions to advance economic growth, make the permitting process more efficient, and drive investment in essential industries such as data centers, life sciences, and clean energy.  Included in the Mass Leads Act is the Permit Extension Act, which extends any permit, certificate, order (however, excluding enforcement orders), and license, determination, variance, waiver, building permit, or other such approval granted by a municipal, regional, or state governmental entity, for the use or development of real property, as well as any environmental approval in effect or in existence between January 1, 2023, and January 1, 2025, for a two-year period after the lawful term of the approval. The extension, however, does not apply to permits issued by federal agencies or subject to federal law.  Nor does it apply to certain specified approvals by the Massachusetts Division of Fisheries and Wildlife, the Department of Energy Resources, the Department of Transportation or the MBTA. Additionally, the Mass Leads Act includes an Act to Safeguard Municipal Permitting, which protects an owner or developer from needing to comply with subsequent zoning changes if the use or construction commences under a special permit or site plan approval within three (3) years after issuance of the special permit or site plan approval. Under prior law, there was only a one (1) year protection from subsequent zoning changes for special permits, and no protection for site plan approvals. The Mass Leads Act also creates a State Permit Regulatory Office under the Executive Office of Economic Development. The director of the Permit Regulatory Office will, among other things, work with other state agencies to expedite the process of obtaining state licenses, permits, and other approvals, establish a State Permit Ombudsman to assist new and expanding businesses, and review or deny municipal priority development site proposals made pursuant to M.G.L. c. 43D. The Act also establishes a separate Regulatory Ombudsman within the Permit Regulatory Office who will help businesses navigate compliance with state regulations and train state agencies on how to identify and lessen the impacts of regulation on small businesses. Key Provisions of the Climate and Clean Energy Siting Law The Climate and Clean Energy Siting Law introduces significant updates designed to streamline permitting processes and establish new statewide policies for clean energy projects. This law focuses on streamlining the permitting review process for clean energy projects, including energy storage projects, by consolidating all state, local, and regional, permits into a single master permit. Under this new system, the State Energy Facilities Siting Board will review all large clean energy projects (more than 25 megawatts of power or 100 megawatts of storage) with a decision required within 15 months from submission of an application. Municipalities will continue to oversee smaller projects, with permits to be issued or rejected within 12 months. If these deadlines are not met the application will be automatically approved, but the legislature may reassess the process if too many applications receive automatic approval. Besides streamlining the process, the law creates a new division of Clean Energy Siting and Permitting within the Department of Energy Resources. The new division is tasked with developing requirements for siting and permitting of small energy projects by local governments. These requirements will standardize the review and approval processes used by municipalities across the Commonwealth. This law lays the groundwork for important statewide policies focused on clean energy procurement and renewable energy sources. It broadens the scope of “clean energy” technologies to include nuclear fission and carbon reducing technologies, while coordinating with neighboring New England states to secure long term contracts with nuclear plants. The new law mandates a significant increase of energy storage capacity targeting 5,000 megawatt hours by 2030 to support renewable energy sources such as wind and solar. The law also simplifies and removes a number of barriers to the installation of electric vehicle charging infrastructure, including providing for broader use of pole-mounted electric vehicle chargers, removal of barriers to use of EV charging infrastructure that may otherwise be imposed by historic district commissions or neighborhood or homeowner associations. The law also codifies a definition of “public service corporations” as it relates to zoning exemptions that may be granted by the Department of Public Utilities or the Energy Facilities Siting Board. Under the legislation, a “public service corporation” refers to any corporation or entity qualified to do business in the Commonwealth that owns, operates, or plans to operate assets or facilities providing essential services such as gas, telecommunication, cable, water, or other similar services to the public. Under prior law, “public service corporations” were not defined by statute, and an unnecessary amount of documentation and analysis needed to be provided in administrative proceedings to establish what, in most cases, was an obvious determination. Lastly, the new climate legislation temporarily expands the jurisdiction of the Land Court’s specialized permit session to include renewable energy and energy storage projects. Given the Court’s expertise with land use permitting, this change should expedite the permitting process and ensure more efficient resolution for these projects in advance of the broader changes to the permitting processes. The approval of the Mass Leads Act and the Climate and Clean Energy Siting Law represents a pivotal step in boosting the Massachusetts economy, supporting continued real estate development, and advancing its climate and clean energy goals. If you have any questions or would like to discuss this Client Alert, please contact Greg Sampson, or any member of Sullivan’s Permitting and Land Use team.
44 Sullivan & Worcester Lawyers Selected as “Best Lawyers” Award Recipients
Boston, MA – Sullivan & Worcester today announced that 44 lawyers were recognized in the 2027 edition of Best Lawyers in America®. 40 of the firm’s lawyers in Boston, New York and Washington, D.C. were selected as “Best Lawyers in America®,” and four Sullivan lawyers were recognized as “Ones to Watch” in the U.S. Best Lawyers in America® The firm’s 2027 Best Lawyers in Boston include Victor Baltera (Environmental Law, Real Estate Law); Howard Berkenblit (Corporate Governance Law, Corporate Law); Harvey Bines (Corporate Compliance Law, Corporate Governance Law, Corporate Law); Ashley Brooks (Real Estate Law); Joel Carpenter (Tax Law); Henry Comstock, Jr. (Trusts and Estates); Christopher Curtis (Tax Law); Patrick Dinardo (Bankruptcy and Creditor Debtor Rights / Insolvency and Reorganization Law, Litigation - Bankruptcy); John Graham (Nonprofit / Charities Law, Tax Law); David Guadagnoli (Employee Benefits (ERISA) Law, Tax Law); Warren Heilbronner (Real Estate Law); Zachary Hyde (Patent Law); Richard Jones (Tax Law); Karen Kepler (Real Estate Law); Caroline Kupiec (Tax Law); Thomas Meyers (Patent Law); Lisa Mingolla (Trusts and Estates); Louis Monti (Real Estate Law); Cornelius Murray III (Trusts and Estates); David Nagle (Litigation and Controversy - Tax, Tax Law); Ameek Ashok Ponda (Tax Law); Gregory Sampson (Environmental Law, Land Use and Zoning Law, Real Estate Law); Lewis Segall (Corporate Law, Mergers and Acquisitions Law); Amy Sheridan (Employee Benefits (ERISA) Law, Tax Law); Laura Steinberg (Commercial Litigation); John Steiner (Real Estate Law); Douglas Stransky (Tax Law); Sarah Wellings (Tax Law); and Amy Zuccarello (Bankruptcy and Creditor Debtor Rights / Insolvency and Reorganization Law, Litigation - Bankruptcy). Sullivan’s 2027 Best Lawyers in Washington, D.C. include John Chilton (Mutual Funds Law); Cameron Cosby (Tax Law); Nicole Crum (Mutual Funds Law); David Leahy (Mutual Funds Law); David Mahaffey (Mutual Funds Law, Securities Regulation); and Stephanie Monaco (Corporate Law, Mutual Funds Law, Private Funds / Hedge Funds Law, Securities Regulation). The firm’s 2027 Best Lawyers in New York include Carole Bass (Trusts and Estates); J. Truman Bidwell, Jr. (Corporate Law); Domenick Pugliese (Mutual Funds Law); Constantine Ralli (Trusts and Estates); and Marc Stern (Trusts and Estates). Best Lawyers: Ones to Watch Awardees Best Lawyers awards this recognition to attorneys who are earlier in their careers for their outstanding professional excellence in private practice in the United States. Sullivan’s lawyers earning this award include Alexander Gansebom (Corporate Governance and Compliance Law, Corporate Law, Health Care Law, Mergers and Acquisitions Law, Real Estate Law); Emily Goldschmidt (Corporate Law); Ryan Rosenblatt (Commercial Litigation); and Ashley Tan (Real Estate Law). Best Lawyers Selection Methodology Recognition by Best Lawyers in America® is based on a peer review process designed to capture the consensus opinion of leading lawyers about the professional abilities of their colleagues within the same geographical and legal practice areas. About Sullivan Sullivan & Worcester (Sullivan) is a premier, AmLaw 200 international law firm with lawyers in Boston, London, New York, Tel Aviv and Washington, D.C. Sullivan’s clients, including Fortune 500 companies, leading financial services firms and asset managers, boards of directors, real estate companies, and emerging businesses, rely on Sullivan’s ability to navigate complex legal and operational landscapes, the impeccable judgment of its lawyers, and its commitment to best-in-class client service.
Sullivan Represents Fattal Hotel Group in Acquisition of The Blakely Hotel in Midtown Manhattan
Sullivan & Worcester represented Fattal Hotel Group, owner and operator of 329 hotels across 22 countries and based in Tel Aviv, in its acquisition and financing of The Blakely Hotel in Midtown Manhattan. The acquisition marks the client's first hotel investment in the United States and is a milestone in its evolution from a leading European hospitality operator into a global hotel group. The acquisition was completed on July 7, 2026. The Sullivan team included Ashley Brooks, Tamir Chagal, Oded Har-Even, Gerry Silver, John Steiner, Nancy Gillman and Ashley Tan. Read more about the transaction here.  

Ashley Tan