Boston, MA - On Friday, March 10, 2023, the Supreme Judicial Court ("SJC") issued its decision in James J. Reagan, Jr. v. Commissioner of Revenue, finding that capital gains arising from the sale of urban redevelopment projects organized and operated under G.L. c. 121A are exempt from Massachusetts taxation. The decision represents a big win for urban renewal and affordable housing efforts in the commonwealth, as well as an important check on the Massachusetts Commissioner of Revenue’s (“Commissioner”) attempts to chip away tax benefits afforded to taxpayers by statute (for more on this trend, see our alert about the SJC’s Decision in Oracle, USA Inc. v. Commissioner of Revenue, here).
The case concerned the application of tax exemptions afforded under G.L. c. 121A, a special regime designed to incentivize the investment of private capital in blighted areas, to capital gain on the sale of three urban redevelopment projects ("121A projects"). Here, the 121A project owners collectively built and maintained more than 500 units of affordable housing and housing designated for the elderly and disabled, while helping to revitalize areas of Boston. Under G.L. c. 121A, the project owners were obligated to pay a special excise on property value and gross receipts and were subject to an annual cap on operating profits and property use restrictions. In exchange, 121A project owners are exempt from "any" Massachusetts state or local tax arising "on account of" a 121A project.
At issue in the case was whether G.L. c. 121A’s exemption applied to capital gain arising from the 2012 sale of the 121A project properties. The Commissioner contended that the gain was not exempt and assessed the 121A project owners, including Mr. Reagan. On appeal, the Massachusetts Appellate Tax Board ("ATB") upheld those assessments based on multiple arguments advanced by the Commissioner.
On behalf of Mr. Reagan, Sullivan attorneys Richard Jones and Caroline Kupiec brought an appeal to the state’s highest court. In their briefs and at the oral argument before the SJC’s seven justices, Attorneys Jones and Kupiec contended that G.L. c. 121A’s broad exemptions must be applied to capital gains and explained why each of the Commissioner’s arguments to the contrary must be rejected. The SJC agreed and reversed the ATB decision. Notably, the SJC disagreed with the Commissioner’s assertion that capital gain on the sale of a 121A project was not "on account" of that 121A project. The SJC also refused to adopt the Commissioner’s notion that the sale of the 121A projects caused the G.L. c. 121A exemption period to end before the capital gains arose. Instead, the SJC agreed with the reasoning articulated by Sullivan attorneys – that the capital gains necessarily arose simultaneously with the sale of the 121A project properties and thus were within the exemption period.
In its decision, the SJC emphasized that both the plain language and legislative intent of G.L. c. 121A clearly mandated the tax exemption of the capital gains from the 121A project property sales. The SJC observed that G.L. c. 121A itself:
|
To this end, the SJC noted the many monetary restrictions that G.L. c. 121A imposes, including a special excise and caps to operating profits, and remarked that “[t]hese other limiting provisions of the statute bolster our construction of the tax concession . . . in order to achieve the codified [legislative] intent."
Importantly, the SJC’s decision has potentially broad beneficial impacts for urban revitalization and affordable housing efforts at a time of limited housing supply for those of lesser means by further incentivizing investment in blighted areas via 121A projects.
* * * * * * * * * *
Richard Jones leads Sullivan & Worcester's Tax Practice Group, and along with Caroline Kupiec, a tax associate, concentrates on SALT and Tax Controversy.
About Sullivan
Sullivan & Worcester (Sullivan) is a leading AmLaw 200 law firm with approximately 200 attorneys in Boston, London, New York, Tel Aviv and Washington, DC. Sullivan’s clients, including Fortune 500 companies and emerging businesses, rely on Sullivan’s strategic vision, comfort with complexity and intense focus on results. As a global law firm, Sullivan’s reach extends beyond the United States. Sullivan has represented clients around the world and has a deep bench for working on a variety of matters and issues affecting clients globally.
Since the publication of this Client Alert on July 30, 2026, several significant developments have affected the implementation of NYC’s Non-Primary Residence Surcharge (the “Pied-à-Terre Tax”), including the NYC Department of Finance (“NYC DOF”) extending the deadline for property owners to submit exemption applications to September 18, 2026. On August 7, 2026, three NYC homeowners filed a lawsuit challenging the City’s implementation of the surcharge, including the City’s process of identifying
Simon Cook, in his role as ITFA's Head of Education, will jointly moderate a Q&A on “The next generation: Three emerging leaders, three ideas”, together with Charlie O'Mulloy, chair of ITFA’s Emerging Leader Committee and Associate Banker at EBRD, at ITFA’s 52nd Annual International Trade and Forfaiting Conference in Split, Croatia on September 9. The Q&A will follow the presentations made by the finalists of the 2026 ITFA Emerging Leader
On July 29, 2026, the Securities and Exchange Commission (the "SEC") notified Nasdaq that it had received notices of intention to petition for review of the SEC's July 22, 2026 order approving Nasdaq's proposed rule change requiring listed companies to maintain a minimum Market Value of Listed Securities ("MVLS") of $5 million. Pursuant to Rule 431(e) of the SEC's Rules of Practice, the July 22, 2026 approval order has been
Sullivan & Worcester represented Datavault AI Inc. (Nasdaq: DVLT), an Artificial Intelligence Platform company focused on data monetization, tokenization and digital asset technologies, in its acquisition of NYIAX, Inc., a pioneer in blockchain-enabled exchange technology and contract management infrastructure. The acquisition adds NYIAX's institutional-grade exchange technology, blockchain settlement infrastructure and portfolio of intellectual property assets to Datavault AI's platform, strengthening the company's capabilities across the digital asset and real-world asset tokenization
Douglas S. Stransky, partner and leader of the Tax Practice Group, has published a new post on the LexisNexis blog examining a recurring problem in cross-border acquisitions: entity classification errors discovered in tax due diligence. Using a hypothetical fact pattern in which a target’s foreign subsidiary never filed its check-the-box election, the post explains why classification mistakes persist, how a missing Form 5471 can leave the assessment statute open indefinitely under
New York City Department of Finance (“NYC DOF”) recently began notifying property owners by mail that they may be subject to the City’s new Non-Primary Residence Surcharge, which will be imposed annually on certain high-value residential properties that are not used as primary residences.[i] Although the surcharge is commonly referred to as the “Pied-à-Terre Tax,” it applies to a broader range of non-primary residences. Receipt of a notice does not necessarily
Sullivan partner Tehila Levi Lati will speak at a webinar held in collaboration with Amazon and Digate titled "Going Live in China" on September 8, 2026. Designed for decision-makers and technical leaders navigating regional expansion, the program will explore key technical, legal and operational considerations for launching in China, including cloud infrastructure, local licensing, data privacy and corporate risk management. During the webinar, Tehila will leverage her deep experience leading Sullivan's China and
Gregory Sampson was quoted in the August 23 Banker & Tradesman article, “A Green Light for Project Lite Brite?,” examining how Massachusetts’ evolving clean energy permitting framework could reshape the development of battery storage and other clean energy projects. The article focuses on Project Lite Brite, a proposed 62,000-square-foot battery storage facility in Boston’s Brighton neighborhood, and explores how Boston’s new clean energy zoning and changes under the state’s 2024 climate
Geoffrey Wynne will participate in a panel discussion at ITFA's 52nd Annual International Trade and Forfaiting Conference alongside Ailsa McNeil, Director at Texel, and Hernan Mayol, Board Member and Representative of ITFA Americas and Chair of ITFA’s Latin America Regional Committee (LARC). The session, titled “Financing the future: From defence to critical raw materials,” will be moderated by Clarissa Dann, Editorial Director at Deutsche Bank AG. The session will explore how trade
Since the publication of this Client Alert on July 30, 2026, several significant developments have affected the implementation of NYC’s Non-Primary Residence Surcharge (the “Pied-à-Terre Tax”), including the NYC Department of Finance (“NYC DOF”) extending the deadline for property owners to submit exemption applications to September 18, 2026. On August 7, 2026, three NYC homeowners filed a lawsuit challenging the City’s implementation of the surcharge, including the City’s process of identifying
Simon Cook, in his role as ITFA's Head of Education, will jointly moderate a Q&A on “The next generation: Three emerging leaders, three ideas”, together with Charlie O'Mulloy, chair of ITFA’s Emerging Leader Committee and Associate Banker at EBRD, at ITFA’s 52nd Annual International Trade and Forfaiting Conference in Split, Croatia on September 9. The Q&A will follow the presentations made by the finalists of the 2026 ITFA Emerging Leader
On July 29, 2026, the Securities and Exchange Commission (the "SEC") notified Nasdaq that it had received notices of intention to petition for review of the SEC's July 22, 2026 order approving Nasdaq's proposed rule change requiring listed companies to maintain a minimum Market Value of Listed Securities ("MVLS") of $5 million. Pursuant to Rule 431(e) of the SEC's Rules of Practice, the July 22, 2026 approval order has been
Sullivan & Worcester represented Datavault AI Inc. (Nasdaq: DVLT), an Artificial Intelligence Platform company focused on data monetization, tokenization and digital asset technologies, in its acquisition of NYIAX, Inc., a pioneer in blockchain-enabled exchange technology and contract management infrastructure. The acquisition adds NYIAX's institutional-grade exchange technology, blockchain settlement infrastructure and portfolio of intellectual property assets to Datavault AI's platform, strengthening the company's capabilities across the digital asset and real-world asset tokenization
Douglas S. Stransky, partner and leader of the Tax Practice Group, has published a new post on the LexisNexis blog examining a recurring problem in cross-border acquisitions: entity classification errors discovered in tax due diligence. Using a hypothetical fact pattern in which a target’s foreign subsidiary never filed its check-the-box election, the post explains why classification mistakes persist, how a missing Form 5471 can leave the assessment statute open indefinitely under
